Lesson 11: Analysing outbreak data
Judge a hand-hygiene program from school data
SkillsAnalysing outbreak dataControlling disease
Worked example
School A started a hand-hygiene program (soap at every sink and supervised hand washing before lunch) at the start of term 2. School B, of similar size and in the same town, did not. The table gives cases of gastroenteritis reported to each school.
| School | Term 1 | Term 2 |
|---|---|---|
| A (program from term 2) | 84 | 39 |
| B (no program) | 80 | 72 |
(a) Calculate the percentage change in cases at each school. (b) Evaluate the claim that the program reduced gastroenteritis at School A by more than half.
Step 1: Percentage changes
School A: . School B: .
Step 2: Why School B matters
Cases fell by at School B with no program, probably because of seasonal or community-wide changes. School B is the comparison (control) group: it shows how much of the fall would have happened anyway.
Step 3: The effect of the program
The fall at School A was about percentage points more than at School B, so the program probably reduced cases, but by less than the whole .
Step 4: Limitations
One term at two schools is a small, short study. The schools were not randomly assigned, so other differences (age of students, a single outbreak in term 1 at School A, how cases were reported) could explain part of the change. Repeating over more terms and more schools would improve confidence.
Step 5: Judgement
The claim is only partly supported. Cases at School A fell by more than half, but School B fell by without any program. If School A had fallen by anyway, it would have had about cases in term 2, and is fewer than that. So the program's own effect is probably a reduction of just under half, and a short two-school study limits confidence even in that.
Answer
(a) A: −53.6 %; B: −10.0 %. (b) Partly supported: the program is associated with a much bigger fall than at the comparison school, but some of the fall would have happened anyway, and a short two-school study limits confidence.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Percentage change = (new − old) ÷ old × 100.
Compare with a group that had no intervention to remove the background change.
Consider other explanations and the size of the study before judging.
Watch out for
Ignoring the comparison school and crediting the program with the whole fall.
Dividing by the new value instead of the old.