Lesson 4 of 9 · 18 min

Investigating enzyme activity

Design an enzyme investigation, calculate rates from volumes and times, process repeated trials with means and uncertainty, and interpret and evaluate the results.

What you will be able to do

  • Design a fair test of the effect of temperature, pH or substrate concentration on an enzyme, with variables, a control and repeats.
  • Calculate a rate from a volume and a time, an initial rate from a graph, and a rate as 1t\frac{1}{t}.
  • Process repeated trials: identify outliers, calculate means, uncertainty and percentage change.
  • Interpret trends and optimum values, and evaluate reliability, validity and possible improvements.

You know from the last lesson what should happen when you heat an enzyme or change its pH. In the laboratory you find out what does happen, with real measurements, real variation between trials and real decisions about what the data can and can't show. This is the skill the data test assesses most.

Three practicals are common in Queensland schools:

  • Catalase and hydrogen peroxide. Catalase (from liver, potato or yeast) splits HX2OX2\ce{H2O2} into water and oxygen. You measure the oxygen collected in a gas syringe or an upturned measuring cylinder, or time how long a filter-paper disc soaked in catalase takes to rise through HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}.
  • Amylase and starch. Every 30 seconds a drop of the mixture goes onto a spotting tile with iodine. Blue-black means starch is still there; when the iodine stays orange-brown, all the starch has been hydrolysed. The time to this end point measures the rate.
  • Proteases and milk. Trypsin hydrolyses the milk protein casein, so cloudy milk slowly turns clear. You time how long it takes for a mark behind the tube to become visible.

Designing a fair enzyme investigation

  1. Choose one independent variable

    The factor you change, with at least five values across a sensible range: for example temperature at 2020, 3030, 4040, 5050 and 60 °C60\unit{°C}, set with water baths.

  2. Decide how to measure the dependent variable

    The rate, from the volume of oxygen after a fixed time, or the time to an end point. Say what you measure, with what, and to what resolution.

  3. Control the other variables

    Keep the same concentration and volume of enzyme and of substrate, the same pH (use a buffer), the same temperature (except when temperature is your independent variable), and the same timing method. Leave enzyme and substrate in the water bath for a few minutes before mixing, so they start at the set temperature.

  4. Include a control

    Repeat with the enzyme boiled (denatured) or replaced by water. If the reaction still happens, something other than the enzyme is causing it.

  5. Repeat

    At least three trials at each value, so you can spot outliers, calculate a mean and judge how reliable the results are.

Calculating a rate. How you calculate the rate depends on what you measured.

  • A volume (or mass, or amount) of product in a time: rate=volumetime\text{rate} = \dfrac{\text{volume}}{\text{time}}, for example in cm3 min−1\mathrm{cm^3\,min^{-1}}.
  • The time for a fixed amount of reaction (an end point): rate=1time\text{rate} = \dfrac{1}{\text{time}}, in s−1\mathrm{s^{-1}}. A longer time means a slower rate.
  • A graph of product against time: the initial rate is the gradient of the steepest, first part of the curve, found by drawing a tangent there. The rate falls later because the substrate is being used up.

Oxygen collected from catalase and HX2OX2\ce{H2O2}. The dashed tangent at the start has a gradient of 301.2=25 cm3 min−1\frac{30}{1.2} = 25\unit{cm^3\,min^{-1}}, the initial rate. The curve levels off when all the HX2OX2\ce{H2O2} has been used.

Worked example

Rates from a catalase gas syringe experiment

  • Simple familiar
  • Technology active

Catalase was added to hydrogen peroxide and the oxygen was collected in a gas syringe.

Time (min)00.51.01.52.02.53.04.05.0
Volume of O₂ (cm³)01017212426282930

(a) Calculate the mean rate of oxygen production over the first 2.0 minutes. (b) Calculate the mean rate between 3.0 and 5.0 minutes. (c) Explain why the rate falls, and why the volume stops at 30 cm³.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Rate = change in volume ÷ change in time over the interval.

  2. A falling rate over time means the substrate is running out.

Watch out for

  • Saying the rate falls because the enzyme is used up or denatured.

  • Dividing the volume at 5 minutes by 5 for the rate between 3 and 5 minutes.

In an amylase experiment the starch–iodine end point was reached after 50 s50\unit{s} at 25 °C25\unit{°C} and after 20 s20\unit{s} at 35 °C35\unit{°C}. Calculate the rate at 35 °C35\unit{°C}, as 1t\frac{1}{t}, in s−1\mathrm{s^{-1}}.

in s -1

Processing repeated trials. Three trials at each value rarely agree exactly. To process them:

  1. Look for an outlier, a result that is clearly different from the others at that value (often from a mistake such as starting the timer late). Leave it out and say so.
  2. Calculate the mean of the remaining trials.
  3. Show the spread as an uncertainty: ±range2\pm\frac{\text{range}}{2}, half the difference between the largest and smallest values used.

A small uncertainty compared with the mean means the results are reliable (repeatable). A difference between two means is convincing only when their uncertainty ranges don't overlap.

Time for trypsin to clear a milk suspension at different temperatures. The value marked * is an outlier.
Temperature (°C)Trial 1 (s)Trial 2 (s)Trial 3 (s)Mean (s)Uncertainty (s)
20412398405405±7
30196204200200±4
4010298163*100±2
50131139135135±4
60no changeno changeno change——

Three trials of a catalase experiment collected 1818, 2222 and 35 cm335\unit{cm^3} of oxygen in two minutes. The 35 cm335\unit{cm^3} trial is an outlier. Calculate the mean volume of oxygen, leaving out the outlier.

in cm 3

Percentage change compares a result with a reference value, such as the rate with an inhibitor against the rate without:

percentage change=new−originaloriginal×100\text{percentage change} = \frac{\text{new} - \text{original}}{\text{original}} \times 100

A negative answer is a decrease. If a rate falls from 12.012.0 to 4.5 cm3 min−14.5\unit{cm^3\,min^{-1}} the change is 4.5−12.012.0×100=−62.5 %\frac{4.5 - 12.0}{12.0} \times 100 = -62.5\,\%, a 62.5 %62.5\,\% decrease.

Exam tip

Reading an optimum from data

The optimum you can claim is the tested value with the highest rate, and the true optimum may lie between tested values. From the trypsin table, the fastest rate was at 40 °C40\unit{°C}, so the optimum is about 40 °C40\unit{°C}, somewhere between 3030 and 50 °C50\unit{°C}. To find it more precisely, repeat with smaller intervals, such as every 2 °C2\unit{°C} from 3434 to 46 °C46\unit{°C}.

Evaluating an enzyme investigation
TermWhat it meansHow to improve it
ReliabilityRepeated trials give similar results (small spread)More repeats; a more objective end point; the same person timing each trial
ValidityThe method tests what it claims, with every other variable controlledBuffer the pH; pre-warm the solutions; use a control; change only one variable
AccuracyResults are close to the true valueBetter instruments: a gas syringe instead of counting bubbles, a colorimeter instead of judging colour by eye
Random errorUnpredictable scatter, such as reaction time with a stopwatchRepeat and average
Systematic errorEvery result is off in the same direction, such as a water bath that runs 2 °C hotCalibrate the equipment; measure the temperature in the tube itself
Interactive

Run the practical

Run catalase with hydrogen peroxide at each temperature, three trials each. Look for outliers, compare the means and uncertainties, and decide where the optimum lies.

Worked example

Analyse an amylase and pH investigation

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

Amylase and starch were mixed in buffers of different pH at 37 °C37\unit{°C}. Drops were tested with iodine every 5 s5\unit{s}, and the time for the iodine to stop turning blue-black was recorded.

pHTrial 1 (s)Trial 2 (s)Trial 3 (s)
4300290310
5150160145
6908595
7606555
87512080
9200210190

(a) Identify the outlier. (b) Calculate the mean time and the rate (1t\frac{1}{t}) at pH 7 and pH 8. (c) State the uncertainty of the mean at pH 7. (d) State the optimum pH and suggest how to find it more precisely. (e) Identify two controlled variables.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Spot and exclude outliers before averaging.

  2. Rate = 1 ÷ mean time; check that longer times give smaller rates.

  3. Uncertainty = ± half the range of the trials used.

  4. The optimum is the tested value with the fastest rate; refine with smaller intervals.

Watch out for

  • Including the outlier, which gives a mean of 91.7 s at pH 8.

  • Taking the longest time as the fastest rate.

A student tests amylase at five temperatures. She takes the starch and amylase solutions from the bench (at 22 °C22\unit{°C}), mixes them and puts the tube straight into each water bath. Which improvement would most increase the validity of her results?

Choose one answer

Summary

  • A fair test changes one independent variable, measures the rate, controls the other variables (enzyme and substrate concentration and volume, pH with a buffer, temperature), includes a control and repeats each value at least three times.

  • Rate = volume ÷ time for a product measured over time; rate = 1/t for the time to an end point. The initial rate is the gradient of the first, steepest part of a product–time graph.

  • Leave out outliers, calculate the mean, and give the uncertainty as ± half the range.

  • Percentage change = (new − original) ÷ original × 100.

  • The optimum is the tested value with the highest rate; smaller intervals around it find it more precisely.

  • Reliability is about repeatability, validity about testing what you claim with variables controlled, accuracy about closeness to the true value.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 4 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account