Lesson 9: Transpiration and its rate
Wind and transpiration in a bean and a banksia
SkillsTranspiration experimentsStomata and guard cells
Worked example
A student investigated the effect of wind on transpiration in two species: a bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) and a coast banksia (Banksia integrifolia), whose stomata sit in hair-lined pits. Each potted plant had its pot sealed in a plastic bag and was weighed before and after 4 hours under a lamp, in still air or in front of a fan.
| Plant | Leaf area () | Condition | Mass lost in 4 h (g), trials 1, 2, 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bean | 320 | Still air | 6.2, 6.6, 6.4 |
| Bean | 320 | Fan | 10.4, 11.2, 10.6 |
| Banksia | 250 | Still air | 2.1, 2.4, 2.4 |
| Banksia | 250 | Fan | 2.9, 3.3, 3.1 |
(a) Calculate the mean rate of transpiration per unit leaf area, in , for each plant and condition. (b) Calculate the percentage increase caused by the fan for each species. (c) Explain the results. (d) Evaluate the reliability and validity of the investigation, and suggest one improvement.
Step 1: Means
Bean: still , fan . Banksia: still , fan .
Step 2: Rates per unit leaf area
Rate :
Bean still: ; bean fan: ; banksia still: ; banksia fan: .
Step 3: Percentage increases
Bean: . Banksia: .
Use the unrounded means where you can: and .
Step 4: Explain the effect of wind
Wind removes the layer of humid air that builds up outside the stomata, steepening the water vapour gradient, so water vapour diffuses out faster in both species.
Step 5: Explain the difference between species
The banksia loses less water per unit area and is less affected by the fan. Its sunken, hair-lined stomata trap still, humid air that the wind cannot easily remove, so the gradient at the pore stays shallow. (A thicker cuticle and fewer stomata would also reduce its rate.)
Step 6: Evaluate
Reliability: the trials are close (bean fan range , about ), so the results are reasonably reliable, but there is only one plant of each species. Validity: per-area rates make the species comparable, and sealing the pot means only transpiration is measured; but a fan may also cool the leaves, and the plants may differ in age and health. Improvement: use at least three plants of each species and monitor temperature and humidity near the leaves.
Answer
(a) Bean 5.0 (still) and 8.4 (fan); banksia 2.3 and 3.1 mg h⁻¹ cm⁻². (b) Bean about 68 %, banksia about 35 %. (c) Wind steepens the water vapour gradient; the banksia's sunken, hairy stomata keep a humid layer, so it loses less and is less affected. (d) Repeats are consistent but there is one plant per species; use more plants and monitor temperature and humidity.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Mean of the trials, then divide by time and leaf area.
Percentage change from the still-air value.
Explain with the water vapour gradient and the structure of the stomata.
Evaluate reliability (spread, repeats) and validity (fair comparison, controlled variables).
Watch out for
Comparing total mass lost when the plants have different leaf areas.
Calling repeat trials on one plant a test of how all bean plants behave.