Lesson 10: Technology inspired by natural systems
Could artificial leaves replace crops as a fuel source?
SkillsTechnology from natural systemsStages of photosynthesis
Worked example
A site receives of sunlight per square metre per day. A biofuel crop stores about 1 % of the sunlight falling on it as chemical energy; a "bionic leaf" device has been reported to store about 10 %.
(a) Calculate the energy stored per square metre per day by each. (b) Calculate the area of crop needed to store as much energy as of bionic leaf. (c) Evaluate the claim that artificial leaves will soon replace crops as a source of fuel.
Step 1: Energy stored by the crop
per day
Step 2: Energy stored by the bionic leaf
per day
Step 3: Equivalent crop area
of crop for each of bionic leaf.
Step 4: Strengths
The device stores about ten times as much of the sunlight per square metre, can make a liquid fuel directly, and does not need farmland, fertiliser or a growing season.
Step 5: Limitations and judgement
It has been demonstrated only at laboratory scale; catalysts and absorbers degrade, some use costly materials, and the device must be built and maintained, while a crop builds and repairs itself from cheap, abundant elements. Judgement: artificial leaves are a promising complement to biofuel crops, but the claim that they will soon replace crops is not yet supported.
Answer
(a) Crop 0.20 MJ m⁻² per day; bionic leaf 2.0 MJ m⁻² per day. (b) 10 m². (c) More efficient per area and makes fuel directly, but only proven at small scale, with durability and cost problems: not yet a replacement.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Energy stored = efficiency × energy received.
Evaluate: strengths, limitations against criteria, then a justified judgement.
Watch out for
Giving only strengths or only limitations in an evaluation.
Writing 10 % as 10 instead of 0.10 in the calculation.