Lesson 10 of 10 · 20 min
Cell size, surface area to volume ratio and diffusion
Calculate surface area to volume ratios, explain how SA:V and the rate of diffusion limit the size of cells, and analyse and evaluate the agar cube investigation.
What you will be able to do
- Calculate the surface area, volume and SA:V ratio of cubes, rectangular prisms and spheres.
- Explain how SA:V and the rate of diffusion limit the size of a cell, and how cell shapes overcome the limit.
- Analyse data from the agar cube investigation, including percentage of volume reached.
- Evaluate the reliability and validity of the investigation and suggest improvements.
Most cells are between 1 µm and 100 µm across. An elephant is not made of bigger cells than a mouse, just more of them. Why can't a single cell simply grow to the size of a grape? The answer is a piece of geometry that limits everything from bacteria to the design of lungs.
Supply and demand. A cell takes in oxygen and nutrients, and gets rid of wastes, across its surface. How much it needs, and how much waste it makes, depends on how much cytoplasm it has: its volume. So the ratio of the two matters:
For a cube of side , the surface is six squares and the volume is :
| Side (cm) | Surface area (cm²) | Volume (cm³) | SA:V |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 | 1 | 6 : 1 |
| 2 | 24 | 8 | 3 : 1 |
| 3 | 54 | 27 | 2 : 1 |
| 4 | 96 | 64 | 1.5 : 1 |
| 6 | 216 | 216 | 1 : 1 |
Key idea
SA:V falls as size increases
As an object gets bigger without changing shape, its surface area increases with the square of its length but its volume with the cube. Doubling the side multiplies the area by 4 but the volume by 8, so the SA:V halves.
A ratio is written as (divide the surface area by the volume), or as a value in or : a 2 cm cube has , or .
Calculate the SA:V ratio of a cube with sides of 5 cm. Write it in the form .
Worked example
Compare the SA:V of a bacterium and an egg cell
Model a spherical bacterium of radius 1 µm and a human egg cell of radius 50 µm as spheres (, ). (a) Calculate the SA:V ratio of each. (b) How many times larger is the bacterium's SA:V?
Step 1: Simplify the ratio for a sphere
The π and the 4 cancel, which saves calculating each area and volume.
Step 2: The bacterium
, so SA:V (or ).
Step 3: The egg cell
, so SA:V .
Step 4: Compare
: the bacterium has 50 times the SA:V. The egg can be so large because it is not very active metabolically until fertilisation and is surrounded by cells that supply it.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Bacterium ; egg . (b) 50 times.
Method
For a sphere, SA:V = 3/r; for a cube, 6/L.
Keep the units the same for both objects.
Watch out for
Using the diameter in place of the radius.
Why diffusion sets the limit. Inside the cell, materials still have to get from the membrane to where they are used, mostly by diffusion. Diffusion is fast over short distances and very slow over long ones: the time it takes grows with the square of the distance. Oxygen diffuses across 10 µm of water in about 0.02 s, across 1 mm in about 4 minutes, and across 1 cm in nearly 7 hours.
So as a cell grows, two things go wrong at once: its SA:V falls, so the supply across the surface cannot keep up with the demand of the volume, and the centre gets further from the surface, so diffusion takes far too long to reach it. A cell much bigger than about 100 µm (in all directions) would starve at its centre and poison itself with its own wastes. When a cell reaches its limit, it divides.
Ways around the limit. Cells that must be large, or that exchange a lot, change their shape instead of being spheres:
- flat: squamous epithelial cells lining the alveoli and capillaries are only fractions of a micrometre thick where gases cross;
- long and thin: neurons and muscle fibres stretch out instead of swelling;
- folded: microvilli on intestinal cells and the long extension of root hair cells add surface without much volume;
- biconcave: a red blood cell has more surface than a sphere of the same volume.
Large organisms solve the same problem at a bigger scale with exchange surfaces (lungs, gut, gills, leaves) and transport systems (blood, xylem) that bring materials within a short diffusion distance of every cell.
A cube-shaped cell 20 µm on each side changes shape into a flat sheet 80 µm × 50 µm × 2 µm, with the same volume. What happens to its SA:V ratio?
The agar cube investigation. You can model cells with cubes of agar jelly made up with a little sodium hydroxide and phenolphthalein indicator, which is pink in alkali. Cut cubes of different sizes (say 1, 2 and 3 cm), put them in dilute hydrochloric acid for a fixed time, then remove, blot and cut each in half. Where the acid has diffused in and neutralised the alkali, the agar turns colourless; the core it has not reached stays pink.
- Independent variable: the size of the cube, and so its SA:V.
- Dependent variable: the depth of the colourless band, used to calculate the percentage of the cube's volume reached in the time (or the time for the cube to turn completely colourless). The percentage reached in a fixed time is how this investigation measures the rate of diffusion into the cube.
- Controlled variables: the concentration, volume and temperature of the acid; the time in acid; the agar recipe (same alkali and indicator concentration); stirring.
Watch the colourless band move in. Compare the depth it reaches in each cube with the percentage of each cube it reaches.
Key idea
What the results show
The acid diffuses the same distance into every cube in the same time. But a smaller cube has a larger SA:V, so that same depth reaches a larger percentage of its volume. For a cube of side with a colourless band of depth on every face, the pink core is a cube of side :
In a cell, that is the difference between every part of the cytoplasm being supplied in time and the centre being starved.
Common mistake
Say which rate you mean
"Diffusion is faster in small cubes" is too vague to earn the mark, and taken literally it is wrong. The acid moves in at about the same distance per minute in every cube. The total amount of acid entering per minute is actually greater for a big cube, because it has more surface. What is greater in the small cube is the rate relative to its volume: the percentage of the cube reached per minute. That is the sense in which SA:V affects the rate of diffusion, so write it that way: "the larger the SA:V, the greater the percentage of the cube's volume the acid reached in 10 minutes."
Percentage of each agar cube's volume reached by acid in 10 minutes, from the results in the worked example below.
Worked example
Analyse and evaluate an agar cube investigation
Agar cubes containing sodium hydroxide and phenolphthalein (pink) were left in 0.1 mol L⁻¹ hydrochloric acid for 10 minutes, then cut in half. The depth of the colourless band was measured with a ruler marked in millimetres, estimating between the marks to 0.1 mm.
| Side of cube (cm) | Depth, trial 1 (mm) | Depth, trial 2 (mm) | Depth, trial 3 (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.2 |
| 2 | 2.5 | 2.4 | 2.6 |
| 3 | 2.6 | 2.5 | 2.4 |
(a) Calculate the SA:V ratio and mean depth for each cube, and the percentage of each cube's volume reached by the acid. (b) Describe the relationship shown and draw a conclusion relevant to cells. (c) Evaluate the reliability of the data and suggest two improvements.
Step 1: (a) SA:V for each cube
: 1 cm cube , 2 cm cube , 3 cm cube .
Step 2: (a) Mean depths
1 cm: ; 2 cm: ; 3 cm: .
Step 3: (a) Percentage reached
With in cm, .
- 1 cm:
- 2 cm:
- 3 cm:
Step 4: (b) Describe the relationship
The depth reached was about the same (2.4–2.5 mm) in every cube, but as the SA:V ratio decreased from to , the percentage of the volume reached fell from 85.9 % to 42.1 %.
Step 5: (b) Conclude for cells
Substances diffuse the same distance into a cell in a given time whatever its size, but a larger cell, with a smaller SA:V, has a much smaller fraction of its volume supplied in that time. Its centre would be short of materials, so cells must stay small, or be flat, long or folded.
Step 6: (c) Evaluate reliability
The three trials for each cube agree closely (ranges of 0.2–0.3 mm), so the results are reliable (repeatable). But the uncertainty of the ruler is (half its smallest division), about 20 % of a 2.5 mm depth and larger than the differences between cubes, so the readings to 0.1 mm claim more precision than the ruler has.
Step 7: (c) Suggest improvements
(1) Measure the band with digital calipers (to ), to reduce the uncertainty. (2) Measure the colour boundary at the same time after cutting, against a white background, by the same person, to make the subjective judgement consistent. Also acceptable: cut cubes with a template and measure their real sides; leave them longer so the bands are deeper.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) SA:V 6:1, 3:1, 2:1; mean depths 2.4, 2.5, 2.5 mm; 85.9 %, 57.8 %, 42.1 % reached. (b) Same depth, but the percentage reached falls as SA:V falls, so large cells cannot be supplied fast enough by diffusion. (c) Trials agree closely (reliable), but the ±0.5 mm ruler uncertainty is large relative to the depths; use calipers and a consistent method of judging the boundary.
Method
Calculate SA:V as 6/L and average the repeat trials.
% reached uses the core of side L − 2d.
Describe the trend with values, then link it to cell size.
Judge reliability from the spread of repeats, precision from the instrument's uncertainty, and suggest specific fixes.
Watch out for
Concluding that acid diffuses faster into small cubes.
Using for the core instead of .
After 10 minutes in acid, a 2 cm agar cube has a colourless band 0.4 cm deep on every face. Calculate the percentage of the cube's volume that the acid has reached, to three significant figures.
Evaluating the investigation. A good evaluation names a specific problem and a specific fix.
- Uncertainty: a ruler marked in millimetres reads to . On a band 2.5 mm deep that is , so small depths are imprecise. Measure with a hand lens or digital calipers.
- Judging the boundary: the change from pink to colourless is gradual, so the reading is subjective. Have the same person measure every cube, against a white background, at a fixed time after cutting.
- Cube size: cubes cut by hand are rarely exact; measure every side and calculate each cube's real SA:V, or cut with a template.
- Reliability: one cube of each size tells you little. Use at least three of each and average them; check that the repeats agree.
- Validity: the cubes are a model, not cells. They have no membrane, and they do not use the substance diffusing in, so they show the geometry of the problem but not the biology of uptake.
Summary
For a cube, SA = 6L² and V = L³, so SA:V = 6/L : 1: it falls as size increases.
A cell's supply depends on its surface area, but its needs on its volume; diffusion is too slow over long distances, so cells must stay small.
Flat, long, folded and biconcave shapes increase SA:V; large organisms add exchange surfaces and transport systems.
In the agar cube investigation the acid diffuses the same depth into every cube, but reaches a larger percentage of the smaller cubes, which have a larger SA:V.
% reached = (L³ − (L − 2d)³) ÷ L³ × 100.
Evaluate with specific errors and fixes: measurement uncertainty, the subjective boundary, cube accuracy, repeats, and the limits of a model.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.