Lesson 8 of 8 · 13 min
Intervals for values and for the mean
Use x̄ and s to estimate an interval that covers a given proportion of individual values of a normal variable, and contrast it with the much narrower confidence interval for μ.
What you will be able to do
- Use and as estimates of and to find an approximate interval covering a proportion of values of a normal variable.
- Compare it with the approximate confidence interval for , and explain the factor between their widths.
- Choose the right interval for a question in context.
A fisheries officer measures 100 randomly caught flathead from an estuary: cm and cm, and the lengths look normally distributed. Two different people ask her two different questions:
- A recreational angler asks: "What length is a typical fish? Between what lengths do most fish fall?"
- A scientist asks: "What is the mean length of all flathead in the estuary?"
Both answers are intervals, and both use 95%, but they are very different intervals.
Where most values lie
If , about 95% of values lie in . Estimate and by and :
About 95% of flathead are roughly between and cm long.
Where the mean lies
The approximate 95% confidence interval for is
We are 95% confident that the mean length of all flathead is between and cm.
Same data, same 95%. The interval for individual lengths (grey) is times as wide as the confidence interval for the mean (orange).
Key idea
Two intervals, two questions
- Individual values of a normal variable: about a proportion lie in . Its width does not shrink as grows; a bigger sample just estimates and better.
- The population mean: the confidence interval . Its width shrinks like .
The ratio of their widths is .
Worked example
An interval for fish lengths and an interval for their mean
A random sample of flathead from an estuary has mean length cm and standard deviation cm. Flathead lengths are approximately normally distributed.
(a) Estimate an interval that contains about 95% of the lengths of flathead in the estuary.
(b) Calculate an approximate 95% confidence interval for the mean length .
(c) The legal minimum length is cm. Estimate the proportion of flathead under the legal length, correct to 3 decimal places.
Step 1: Estimate the interval for individual lengths
Estimate and by and . About 95% of a normal population lies within standard deviations of the mean: cm.
Step 2: Calculate the confidence interval for the mean
, so the interval is cm.
Step 3: Compare the two
The first interval is times as wide. It describes individual fish; the second describes the population mean.
Step 4: Estimate the proportion under 35 cm
Model lengths as . .
This is about individual fish, so use , not .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) About cm. (b) cm. (c) About , or 8.1% of flathead.
Method
Individual values: (needs a roughly normal variable).
Population mean: .
For a proportion of individuals, model .
Watch out for
Using the confidence interval to say where most fish lengths are.
Using in part (c), which gives a proportion of essentially zero.
Times to complete a puzzle are normally distributed. A random sample of times has s and s. Use these to estimate an interval containing about 95% of all completion times. Give the endpoints correct to 2 decimal places.
From a random sample of values, Kai calculates an interval containing about 90% of individual values and an approximate 90% confidence interval for . How many times wider is the first interval than the second?
Common mistake
The interval for values needs a normal population
The central limit theorem makes approximately normal, but it does nothing for individual values. covers about 95% of values only if the variable itself is roughly normal. For skewed data such as incomes it can be badly wrong, even when the confidence interval for is fine.
Exam tip
Read which question is being asked
"Most customers", "a randomly chosen bag", "an individual" → interval for values, . "The mean", "on average across all", "the population mean" → confidence interval, . Say which one you are using and why.
Summary
For a normal variable, about a proportion of values lie in , with and estimating and .
The confidence interval for , , is times narrower.
More data narrows the confidence interval but not the spread of individual values.
The interval for values needs a normal population; the confidence interval needs only a large sample.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.