Lesson 8: Proof by contradiction and irrational numbers
The diagonal of a square tile
SkillsProving irrationalityProof by contradiction
Worked example
A tiler says that if she chooses the side length of a square tile carefully (say 30 cm, or 12.5 cm), the diagonal can be measured exactly as a whole number, or at least an exact fraction, of centimetres.
Given that is irrational, prove that a square whose side length is a rational number of centimetres never has a rational diagonal.
Step 1: Model the problem
Let the side length be cm, where and . By Pythagoras, the diagonal is cm.
Turning the claim into a statement about numbers is the unfamiliar part: "rational diagonal" means .
Step 2: Assume the opposite
Assume, for contradiction, that is rational: with , . Write with .
Step 3: Make √2 the subject
, where and is a non-zero integer (since and ).
Dividing by is allowed because .
Step 4: Contradiction
So , which contradicts being irrational.
Step 5: Conclude in context
Hence the diagonal of a square with rational side length is irrational. For a 30 cm tile it is cm, which no exact fraction of a centimetre equals; the tiler can only measure an approximation.
Answer
If the diagonal were rational, would be a ratio of rationals and hence rational, a contradiction. So the diagonal is always irrational.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Translate the claim into a statement about rational and irrational numbers.
Assume the opposite and isolate the known irrational number.
Show it would be rational, and conclude in the context.
Watch out for
Checking a few side lengths with a calculator: a decimal display can never show that a number is irrational.