Lesson 8: Proof by contradiction and irrational numbers
A rational plus an irrational is irrational
SkillsProof by contradictionProving irrationality
Worked example
(a) Prove that if and , then .
(b) Hence show that is irrational.
Step 1: Assume the opposite
Let and , and assume, for contradiction, that for some .
Step 2: Make x the subject
.
Step 3: Show s − r is rational
Write and with and . Then , where and is a non-zero integer. So .
This uses the definition of rational, rather than just saying "the difference of rationals is rational".
Step 4: Contradiction and conclusion
This contradicts . Hence is irrational.
Step 5: Apply to 3 + √2
and , so by (a), .
Answer
If were rational, would be rational, a contradiction. So is irrational.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Assume the combination is rational.
Rearrange to make the known irrational the subject.
Show the other side is rational, and point out the contradiction.
Watch out for
Trying to prove (b) by squaring: only moves the problem.