Lesson 4: Examples and counterexamples
Sums of irrational numbers
SkillsExamples and counterexamplesNumber sets and notation
Worked example
(a) Disprove the statement "the sum of any two irrational numbers is irrational".
(b) Hence decide whether " such that " is true.
Step 1: Choose two irrationals that cancel
Let and . Both are irrational: if were a rational , then would be rational.
Step 2: Add them
, and .
Step 3: Conclude (a)
Two irrational numbers have a rational sum, so the statement is false.
Step 4: Answer (b)
The statement in (b) is the negation of the statement in (a), and the same pair is an example of it. So (b) is true.
A counterexample to a "for all" statement is an example for its "there exists" negation.
Answer
(a) and are irrational, but their sum is rational. (b) True: the same pair works.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Look for irrationals whose irrational parts cancel, such as and .
Show each chosen number really is irrational, and that the result is rational.
Watch out for
Using as an irrational number: .