Lesson 4: Examples and counterexamples
Disproving a statement about squares
SkillExamples and counterexamples
Worked example
Prove or disprove: for all , if then .
Step 1: Test some values
: and . Positive values seem to work, so the trouble, if any, is with negatives.
Trying cases is how you find a counterexample, and how you decide whether to look for a proof instead.
Step 2: Choose a negative a
Let and . Then and , so : the hypothesis holds.
Step 3: Check the conclusion
and , so : the conclusion fails.
Step 4: Conclude
The hypothesis is true and the conclusion is false for , , so the statement is false.
Answer
The statement is false. Counterexample: , gives , but .
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Test cases, especially negatives, zero and fractions.
Pick one value that makes the hypothesis true and the conclusion false.
Show both calculations and state the conclusion.
Watch out for
Choosing , : then , so the hypothesis fails and it is not a counterexample.