Lesson 4: Obedience, conformity and social norms
Analyse social influence in a new workplace
SkillsObedience, conformity and normsCompliance, identification, internalisationStatus, roles and power
Worked example
Sam, 17, starts a casual job at a café. On the first shift the manager tells Sam to wipe down every table after customers leave, and Sam does. Sam notices that the other casuals all skip their breaks on busy days, and starts skipping breaks too, though Sam thinks breaks are important. A poster in the staff room says "Most of our team wash their hands every 30 minutes", and Sam's handwashing increases.
Analyse the three influences on Sam's behaviour, identifying the process in each and explaining how it changed Sam's behaviour. (6 marks)
Step 1: The tables
Obedience. A direct instruction from the manager, who holds legitimate power (and reward power over shifts), so Sam did what the manager said.
Step 2: The breaks
Conformity through normative influence: no one told Sam to skip breaks, but Sam matched the group to fit in, while privately believing breaks matter. In Kelman's terms this is compliance: public behaviour without private acceptance, likely to stop when the group is not watching.
The private disagreement is the evidence for compliance rather than internalisation.
Step 3: The handwashing
A positive descriptive norm ("most of our team wash their hands…"), the kind of message Cialdini et al. (2006) recommend: it tells Sam the desired behaviour is common, so Sam does it more.
Step 4: Compare the three
Obedience had an explicit command from a higher-status person; conformity and the norm had none. The descriptive norm changed behaviour by information about what others do; conformity to the casuals worked through the wish to be accepted.
Answer
Tables: obedience to the manager's legitimate power. Breaks: conformity by normative influence, a form of compliance since Sam privately disagrees. Handwashing: a positive descriptive norm that shows the behaviour is common. Only obedience involved a direct instruction from authority.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
For each behaviour ask: was there an instruction from authority (obedience), a group to match (conformity), or a message about what people do or approve (a norm)?
Add the mechanism (legitimate power, normative or informational influence, descriptive or injunctive norm).
Use the evidence in the scenario.
Watch out for
Calling the breaks obedience because the casuals are co-workers. No one gave an instruction.
Calling the poster injunctive: it states what people do, not what they should do.