Lesson 9: Attraction
Use Buss et al. (1990) to evaluate two explanations
SkillsEvolution, culture and attractionResearch methods and data
Worked example
In Buss et al. (1990), 9,474 people in 37 samples ranked 13 characteristics of a potential partner from 1 (most desirable) to 13. Mean ranks across all samples:
| Characteristic | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Kind and understanding | 2.82 | 2.51 |
| Physically attractive | 5.57 | 7.29 |
| Good earning capacity | 9.86 | 7.97 |
In addition, chastity was the characteristic on which cultures varied most: men in China rated it the 3rd most important of 18 characteristics, while men in the Netherlands rated it last (18th).
Evaluate how well these data support a biological and a cultural explanation of attraction.
Step 1: Read the scale correctly
A lower mean rank means more desirable. "Kind and understanding" was ranked near the top by both sexes.
Reading a rank as a score is the most common error with these data.
Step 2: Evidence for the biological explanation
Men ranked physical attractiveness higher (5.57) than women (7.29), and women ranked good earning capacity higher (7.97) than men (9.86). These are the differences parental investment theory predicts, and they appeared consistently across cultures.
Step 3: Evidence for the cultural explanation
Chastity's importance varied enormously, from 3rd in China to 18th in the Netherlands. Such large differences between cultures in the same characteristic are best explained by learned cultural norms.
Step 4: What both share
Kindness topped both sexes' rankings, and the sex differences, though consistent, were small compared with the shared preferences.
Step 5: Judge
The data support both explanations, for different characteristics: the sex differences in looks and resources fit the biological explanation, while the variation in chastity supports the cultural one. Limitations weaken both: stated preferences by self-report, mostly urban, educated samples, and US-made instruments. The sex differences can also be explained socially, by gender roles.
Answer
Sex differences in the ranking of physical attractiveness (men 5.57, women 7.29) and earning capacity (women 7.97, men 9.86) support the biological explanation; the wide cultural variation in chastity (3rd in China, 18th in the Netherlands) supports the cultural explanation. Both explanations are partly supported, and both are limited by self-report and unrepresentative samples.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check which direction the scale runs.
Match each finding to the explanation it supports.
Weigh the evidence and its limitations before judging.
Watch out for
Treating a higher mean rank as more important. Rank 1 is most desirable.
Concluding that biology explains attraction because of the sex differences, ignoring the larger shared preferences and cultural variation.