Lesson 3: WEIRD research and international collaboration
Analyse a cross-cultural comparison
SkillsResearch methods across culturesWEIRD samples and collaboration
Worked example
A researcher measures the strength of the Müller-Lyer illusion in 30 adults who grew up in a city and 30 adults who grew up in a rural area with few straight-edged buildings. The city group's illusion is significantly stronger ().
(a) Identify the type of investigation, the independent variable and the dependent variable. (b) Explain why the researcher cannot conclude that growing up among straight-edged buildings causes a stronger illusion.
Step 1: Identify the investigation type
Participants cannot be randomly allocated to where they grew up, so this is a quasi-experiment comparing pre-existing groups.
Step 2: Identify the variables
IV: where the participants grew up (city or rural). DV: the strength of the illusion, for example how much longer one line must be before the two look equal.
Step 3: Identify confounding variables
The groups may also differ in schooling, familiarity with drawings and tests, age, eyesight or time spent on screens. Any of these could explain the difference.
Step 4: Conclude
Without random allocation, the difference may be due to these confounds, so the study shows a difference between the groups, not its cause.
Answer
(a) Quasi-experiment; IV: where participants grew up (city or rural); DV: strength of the illusion. (b) Participants could not be randomly allocated to their environment, so the groups may differ in other ways (schooling, experience with drawings, age) that could explain the difference.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Watch out for
Calling it an independent groups experiment. That needs random allocation to conditions.