Lesson 4: Loudness, pitch and timbre
Explain why a violin and a flute sound different
SkillLoudness, pitch and timbre
Worked example
A violin and a flute both play the A at 440 Hz, equally loudly. Explain why a listener perceives the same pitch and loudness but can still tell the instruments apart. (3 marks)
Step 1: Same pitch
Both notes have the same fundamental frequency, 440 Hz, and pitch depends mainly on frequency, so the pitch is the same.
Step 2: Same loudness
Played equally loudly, the waves have about the same amplitude, so the loudness is the same.
Step 3: Different timbre
Each instrument adds harmonics (880 Hz, 1320 Hz, …) in different strengths, and its notes start and fade differently. The waves therefore differ in complexity, which is heard as different timbre.
Answer
Same frequency (440 Hz) gives the same pitch and the same amplitude the same loudness; the instruments differ in the mix of harmonics (complexity of the wave), which is perceived as different timbre.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Match each quality to its property: loudness to amplitude, pitch to frequency, timbre to complexity.
Watch out for
Saying the violin has a "higher pitch" because it sounds brighter. Brightness here is timbre.