Lesson 9 of 11 · 18 min
Retrieval and forgetting
Contrast recall, recognition and relearning, calculate a savings score, and explain forgetting by encoding failure, retrieval failure and proactive and retroactive interference.
What you will be able to do
- Contrast free recall, cued recall, recognition and relearning as ways of retrieving and measuring memory.
- Calculate a savings score.
- Describe Tulving and Pearlstone's (1966) investigation of cued recall and what it shows about forgetting.
- Identify and explain encoding failure, retrieval failure and proactive and retroactive interference in a scenario.
In a multiple-choice question you spot the right answer at once; asked the same thing as a short-answer question, your mind goes blank. You did not forget the answer between the two questions. The two questions asked your memory to do different jobs, and one is much easier than the other.
| Method | What the person does | Cues given | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free recall | Produces the information with no cues | None | Write down every word you remember from the list |
| Serial recall | Produces the information in the order it was learnt | None | Recite the planets in order from the Sun |
| Cued recall | Produces the information when given a hint | Some (a category, a first letter) | Name the fruit on the list; the word began with P |
| Recognition | Identifies the information as previously learnt when it is presented | The information itself | A multiple-choice question; picking a face from a line-up |
| Relearning | Learns the information again; memory shows as time or trials saved | All of it | Relearning a language you learnt as a child |
Recall asks you to search memory and produce the information. Recognition gives you the information and asks only whether it matches what you stored, which needs far less retrieval, so people recognise more than they recall. Relearning is the most sensitive of all: even when you cannot recall or recognise something, learning it again is faster than learning it the first time, which shows that some memory was kept.
The relearning method was invented by Hermann Ebbinghaus (1885), who learnt lists of nonsense syllables (such as DAX and BOK) until he could recite them perfectly, then relearnt them after delays. He measured memory as the savings: how much less time the relearning took. After 20 minutes he saved 58.2% of the original learning time; after a day, 33.7%; after 31 days, still 21.1%. Forgetting is fast at first and then slows, and some memory remains long after nothing can be recalled.
Hana took 24 trials to learn a list of Indonesian words perfectly. A month later Hana could recall none of them, but relearnt the list perfectly in 10 trials. Calculate the savings score, to the nearest whole number.
Worked example
Calculate and interpret savings scores
A researcher taught participants a list of 15 Japanese words. It took them a mean of 12 trials to learn the list perfectly. One week later they recalled a mean of 3 words, recognised a mean of 10 words from a list that also contained 15 new words, and took a mean of 5 trials to relearn the list perfectly.
(a) Calculate the savings score. (b) Rank recall, recognition and relearning from least to most sensitive, using the data.
Step 1: (a) Substitute into the savings formula
Step 2: (b) Express recall and recognition as percentages
Recall: of the words. Recognition: .
Step 3: (b) Rank the measures
Recall (20%) found the least memory, recognition (66.7%) more, and relearning showed that 58.3% of the learning effort was saved even for words that could not be recalled. Least to most sensitive: recall, recognition, relearning.
Recall needs the person to produce the item with no cues; recognition presents it; relearning detects memory too weak to be recognised.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 58.3%. (b) Recall (20% of words), then recognition (66.7%), then relearning (58.3% savings, showing memory for words that could not be recalled): least to most sensitive.
Method
Savings = (original − relearning) ÷ original × 100.
Convert recall and recognition to percentages of the items learnt.
Watch out for
Dividing by the relearning trials instead of the original trials.
Study a list once, then try free recall, cued recall, recognition and relearning. Each measure finds more than the last. Results stay in this browser and are for learning only.
History
Tulving and Pearlstone (1966)
Aim. To find out whether information that cannot be recalled has been lost, or is stored but cannot be reached.
Participants. 948 high school students in Years 10 to 12, randomly assigned to conditions within their classes.
Procedure. Participants heard lists of words that belonged to categories, each word presented with its category name (for example four-footed animals: cow, rat). Then one group was asked to recall the words freely (free recall), and the other was given the category names as cues (cued recall).
Findings. The cued group recalled many more words. The biggest difference was for 48-word lists with one word per category: 19.8 more words recalled with cues, 126% more. When the free recall group was then given the category names, they too recalled many of the words they had missed.
Conclusion. Words that could not be recalled freely were still stored (available) but could not be reached without a cue (not accessible). Much forgetting is retrieval failure, not loss.
In Tulving and Pearlstone's (1966) experiment, identify the independent variable and the dependent variable.
Why we forget. The syllabus names three problems. Each points to a different stage of memory.
| Problem | What has gone wrong | Clue in a scenario |
|---|---|---|
| Encoding failure | The information never got into long-term memory, usually because it was not attended to or processed deeply enough. | No cue helps; the person never really noticed it (the details of a coin, a name said during an introduction while they were distracted). |
| Retrieval failure | The information is stored but cannot be reached, usually because the right cue is missing. | It comes back later or with a cue; the tip-of-the-tongue feeling; remembering when you return to the place you learnt it. |
| Proactive interference | Old information disrupts retrieval of newer information. | The person gives the old answer: last year's timetable, an old password. |
| Retroactive interference | New information disrupts retrieval of older information. | The person cannot recall the old answer because of something learnt since: after learning Spanish, French words are harder to recall. |
Two lists learnt one after the other. Raise the similarity between them and watch interference grow. Switch problem to see encoding and retrieval failure.
Classify each memory problem.
Common mistake
How to tell encoding failure from retrieval failure
If a cue, a reminder or a return to the original place brings the memory back, it was stored, so the problem was retrieval. If nothing brings it back because the person never attended to it, it was an encoding failure. "She forgot" is not an answer; say which stage failed and give the evidence from the scenario.
Worked example
Explain a memory failure with evidence from the scenario
Tom changed schools this year. In his first French lesson at the new school he kept using the vocabulary from his old textbook instead of the new one, although he had studied the new list. When his old friend asked him a month later for the old school's bell times, he could not remember them, although he had followed them for three years.
Identify and explain the two memory problems.
Step 1: The first problem
Old learning (the old textbook's vocabulary) disrupted the retrieval of newer learning (the new list): proactive interference.
The interference runs forward in time, from old to new.
Step 2: The second problem
The new school's bell times, learnt more recently, disrupted retrieval of the old bell times: retroactive interference.
The interference runs backward, from new to old. Similar material (two sets of vocabulary, two timetables) interferes most.
Step 3: Rule out the alternatives
It is not encoding failure: Tom had studied the new list and used the old times for years, so both were encoded. The similarity between the old and new material is what makes interference the best explanation.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The French vocabulary is proactive interference (old learning disrupting new); the bell times are retroactive interference (new learning disrupting old). Both sets were encoded, and similar material interferes most.
Method
Decide which information is old and which is new.
Old disrupts new: proactive. New disrupts old: retroactive.
Give the evidence that the information was encoded.
Watch out for
Reversing the two kinds: "retro" means backwards in time.
Summary
Free recall gives no cues, cued recall some, recognition presents the information itself, and relearning measures savings: each is more sensitive than the last.
Savings = (original − relearning) ÷ original × 100; savings show memory is kept even when nothing can be recalled.
Tulving and Pearlstone (1966): category cues greatly increased recall, so much forgetting is retrieval failure (available but not accessible).
Encoding failure: never stored. Retrieval failure: stored but not reached without a cue.
Proactive interference: old disrupts new. Retroactive interference: new disrupts old.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.