Lesson 4: The working memory model
Explain why working memory explains more
SkillsThe working memory modelComparing models of memory
Worked example
In a dual-task experiment, participants learnt a list of words while doing one of three secondary tasks: repeating "the, the, the" aloud, tracing a pattern with a finger, or nothing. Recall was much lower with repeating "the" than with tracing, and tracing lowered recall only slightly compared with doing nothing.
Explain how the working memory model accounts for these results, and why the multi-store model cannot.
Step 1: Identify the component each task needs
Learning words loads the phonological loop. Saying "the, the, the" also loads the loop's articulatory control process. Tracing a pattern loads the visuospatial sketchpad.
Step 2: Explain the large drop
Repeating "the" uses the same component as rehearsing the words, so the words cannot be rehearsed and recall falls a lot.
Step 3: Explain the small drop
Tracing uses a different component, so the words can still be rehearsed. The small drop comes from the central executive, which coordinates both tasks and has limited capacity.
Step 4: Why the multi-store model cannot explain it
The multi-store model has a single short-term store. Any second task should take up the same limited capacity, so it predicts similar interference from both secondary tasks. It cannot explain why one task interferes much more than the other.
Answer
Repeating "the" and learning words both need the phonological loop, so they interfere strongly; tracing needs the visuospatial sketchpad, so it interferes little (only through the shared central executive). A single STM predicts equal interference from both, so the multi-store model cannot explain the difference.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Assign each task to a component.
Same component: strong interference. Different components: little (central executive only).
Show what a single store would predict, and that it does not fit.
Watch out for
Saying tracing has no effect at all: both tasks still draw on the central executive.