Lesson 5: The levels of processing model
Classify orienting tasks and predict recall
SkillLevels of processing
Worked example
Three groups of participants saw the same 30 words. Group A counted the letters in each word. Group B thought of a word that rhymed with each. Group C rated how useful each object would be on a deserted island. None was told there would be a memory test. Then all were asked to recall the words.
Identify the level of processing in each group, and predict the order of their recall from best to worst, with a reason.
Step 1: Group A
Counting letters uses only the word's appearance: structural (shallow) processing.
Step 2: Group B
Finding a rhyme uses the word's sound: phonemic (intermediate) processing.
Step 3: Group C
Judging usefulness requires thinking about what each object is and does: semantic (deep) processing.
Step 4: Predict the order
Group C > Group B > Group A. Deeper processing at encoding produces a stronger, more durable memory trace (Craik & Lockhart, 1972).
Because no group expected a test, the orienting task is the only processing the words received, so differences in recall can be put down to the level of processing.
Answer
A structural, B phonemic, C semantic. Recall: C best, then B, then A, because deeper processing gives more durable memories.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Appearance → structural; sound → phonemic; meaning → semantic.
Predict recall in order of depth: semantic > phonemic > structural.
Watch out for
Calling rhyming deep processing: it uses sound, not meaning.