Lesson 9: Retrieval and forgetting
Explain a memory failure with evidence from the scenario
SkillWhy we forget
Worked example
Tom changed schools this year. In his first French lesson at the new school he kept using the vocabulary from his old textbook instead of the new one, although he had studied the new list. When his old friend asked him a month later for the old school's bell times, he could not remember them, although he had followed them for three years.
Identify and explain the two memory problems.
Step 1: The first problem
Old learning (the old textbook's vocabulary) disrupted the retrieval of newer learning (the new list): proactive interference.
The interference runs forward in time, from old to new.
Step 2: The second problem
The new school's bell times, learnt more recently, disrupted retrieval of the old bell times: retroactive interference.
The interference runs backward, from new to old. Similar material (two sets of vocabulary, two timetables) interferes most.
Step 3: Rule out the alternatives
It is not encoding failure: Tom had studied the new list and used the old times for years, so both were encoded. The similarity between the old and new material is what makes interference the best explanation.
Answer
The French vocabulary is proactive interference (old learning disrupting new); the bell times are retroactive interference (new learning disrupting old). Both sets were encoded, and similar material interferes most.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Decide which information is old and which is new.
Old disrupts new: proactive. New disrupts old: retroactive.
Give the evidence that the information was encoded.
Watch out for
Reversing the two kinds: "retro" means backwards in time.