Lesson 8: Comparing the three theories, and learning in everyday life
Compare operant conditioning and social learning theory
SkillComparing theories of learning
Worked example
Compare operant conditioning and social learning theory as explanations of how a teenager learns to skateboard, referring to their underlying theories.
Step 1: Choose matched features
How learning happens; whether the learner must perform the behaviour; the role of consequences; the role of thinking; the underlying theory.
Step 2: How learning happens
In operant conditioning the teenager learns by trying moves and having the ones that work reinforced (staying upright, landing a trick) and the ones that fail punished (falling). Whereas in social learning theory they learn by watching other skaters (models) and imitating them.
Step 3: Performance and consequences
Both theories give consequences a role. In operant conditioning the teenager's own consequences shape the behaviour, so it must be performed to be learnt. In social learning theory, seeing a model admired for a trick (vicarious reinforcement) motivates performing it, and a trick can be learnt by watching before it is ever tried.
Step 4: Role of thinking
Operant conditioning, as a behaviourist theory, explains learning only by observable behaviour and consequences. Social learning theory, from social and cognitive psychology, adds attention to the model, memory of the move, the ability to reproduce it, and motivation.
Step 5: Sum up
Social learning theory explains how a new trick is first learnt by watching; operant conditioning explains how practice and its consequences refine and maintain it.
Answer
Both explain the learning partly through consequences, but operant conditioning (behaviourist) requires the teenager to perform the moves and be reinforced or punished, with no role for thinking, whereas social learning theory (social and cognitive) explains learning by observing models, vicarious reinforcement and the cognitive processes of attention, retention, reproduction and motivation, and allows learning before performance.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.