Lesson 9 of 9 · 20 min

Brain research, data and recovery from injury

Use case studies, experiments, correlations and treatment trials from behavioural neuroscience, analyse their data with the course statistics, and explain how plasticity helps recovery from brain injury.

What you will be able to do

  • Identify the design, variables and limitations of a brain research study: case study, experiment, correlational study or treatment trial.
  • Calculate and interpret means, standard deviations, standard errors and confidence intervals, and use a tt-test or Pearson's rr with its pp-value to draw a conclusion.
  • Explain how plasticity (rerouting, sprouting and reorganisation) assists recovery from brain injury.
  • Consider how psychologists use findings from behavioural neuroscience.

Everything in this topic came from research: a stroke patient who lost speech, a man who could no longer form memories, people timed as they react, and patients whose symptoms were scored before and after a treatment. The data test (IA1) gives you two to four unseen datasets like these and asks three kinds of question: apply your understanding to determine an unknown, analyse the data for trends, patterns and limitations, and interpret the evidence to draw a conclusion.

How behavioural neuroscience finds things out
MethodExampleStrengthLimitation
Case study of brain damageBroca's patient Leborgne; Henry Molaison (H.M.) after his hippocampi were removedShows what a region is needed for; studies rare cases in depthOne person: may not generalise; the damage is rarely confined to one area; no before-injury data
ExperimentReaction times with the dominant and non-dominant handThe IV is manipulated and other variables controlled, so cause and effect can be inferredLaboratory tasks may not reflect everyday behaviour
Correlational studyHippocampus size on MRI and score on a memory testStudies variables that cannot be manipulated (brain size, injury)Shows a relationship, not a cause
Treatment trialSymptom scores before and after a new medicineMeasures whether a treatment helps real patientsWithout a placebo control group, improvement may be due to expectation or time

A treatment trial. A neurologist tests a new medicine for the movement symptoms of Parkinson's disease. Ten people are scored on a motor rating scale (higher scores mean more severe symptoms) before and after four weeks of the medicine. Each person is measured twice, so this is a repeated measures design and the data are paired. These data are hypothetical.

Motor symptom scores before and after four weeks of treatment (hypothetical data)
ParticipantBeforeAfter
13831
24236
33533
44738
54035
63330
74540
83935
94437
103734
Interactive

Analyse the treatment trial

Each line joins one person's two scores. Try the error bars and the two tests.

Worked example

Analyse a treatment trial with a paired t-test

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

Ten people with Parkinson's disease were scored on a motor symptom scale (higher = more severe) before and after four weeks of a new medicine (hypothetical data).

Participant12345678910
Before38423547403345394437
After31363338353040353734

(a) Calculate the mean and standard deviation of the scores before and after treatment, to 2 decimal places. (b) Identify the appropriate tt-test and justify your choice. (c) A paired tt-test gives t=7.39t = 7.39, df=9df = 9, p<0.001p < 0.001. Draw a conclusion about the hypothesis that the medicine changes motor symptom scores.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Means and sample SDs to 2 decimal places.

  2. Repeated measures or matched → paired; independent groups → unpaired.

  3. Compare pp with 0.05; state the decision, then the limitation.

Watch out for

  • Using the population SD.

  • Concluding the medicine "works" without mentioning the missing control group.

Key idea

Significant does not mean the medicine works

The paired tt-test gives p<0.001p < 0.001, so the fall in scores is statistically significant: it is very unlikely to be chance. But with no control group, the fall could come from expectation (a placebo effect), from the raters knowing the medicine had been given, or from practice at the motor tasks. A better design would randomly allocate people to the medicine or a placebo, with a double-blind procedure.

Identify the main limitation of the trial above that prevents the researcher concluding that the medicine caused the improvement.

Choose one answer

A correlational study. After a stroke, recovery of arm movement varies a lot. A rehabilitation team records how many hours of arm therapy each of 10 patients completed in 8 weeks and how much their arm function score improved (hypothetical data).

Interactive

Therapy hours and recovery

Pearson's rr is about 0.78 with pp about 0.008. Drag a point to see how one patient changes the result.

For these 10 patients, r=0.78r = 0.78 and p=0.008p = 0.008. Which conclusion is justified?

Choose one answer

Note

What is examined where

Plasticity in recovery and how psychologists use behavioural neuroscience are Science as a human endeavour points: they may be assessed in the internal assessments, such as a research investigation, but not in the external examination. The data skills in this lesson are tested in the data test.

Definition

Plasticity in recovery from brain injury

Neural plasticity is the brain's ability to change its structure and function in response to experience or injury. After a stroke or head injury, the neurons that survive can take over some of the lost functions, so a person can recover abilities that seemed lost.

How plasticity helps recovery
ProcessWhat happens
ReroutingUndamaged neurons near the injury form new connections with other neurons, creating new pathways around the damage.
SproutingSurviving neurons grow new branches on their axons and dendrites, forming new synapses.
Reorganisation (remapping)Neighbouring areas of the cortex, or the matching area in the other hemisphere, take over the function of the damaged area.

Recovery depends on the size and place of the damage, on age (the younger brain is more plastic, so children often recover more fully than adults) and on practice. Plasticity is driven by use: in constraint-induced movement therapy, the unaffected arm of a stroke patient is restrained in a mitt for much of the day, so the affected arm must be used intensively, and arm function improves more than with ordinary therapy (Taub, Uswatte & Pidikiti 1999). Plasticity also works in healthy brains: London taxi drivers, who learn the city's thousands of streets, had a larger rear part of the hippocampus than people who did not drive taxis, and the longer they had driven, the larger it was (Maguire et al. 2000).

Explain how constraint-induced movement therapy uses plasticity to help a person recover the use of their arm after a stroke.

Write it out as you would in an exam. Put maths between dollar signs, like $x^2 + 1$. Worth 1 mark.

0 / 4000

How psychologists use these findings. Clinical neuropsychologists use what is known about localisation to assess a person after a brain injury (which tests of language, memory or attention they fail tells where the damage is likely to be) and to plan rehabilitation. Knowing that memory is distributed explains why a person with hippocampal damage can still learn new skills, which therapists use to teach routines. Knowing how neurotransmitters work underpins medicines for Parkinson's disease, depression and anxiety. And research like the reaction time studies informs road safety rules about fatigue and alcohol.

Worked example

Reaction times with each hand (data test)

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

Twelve right-handed students caught a dropped ruler with each hand, in a counterbalanced order, and their reaction times were calculated (hypothetical data). The results were:

HandMean (ms)SD (ms)
Dominant (right)217.5813.48
Non-dominant (left)230.4216.47

A paired tt-test gave t=8.05t = 8.05, df=11df = 11, p<0.001p < 0.001.

(a) Calculate the standard error of the mean for the non-dominant hand, to 2 decimal places. (b) Identify the trend in the data. (c) Interpret the results with reference to the hypothesis that reaction times differ between the hands, and suggest a brain-based explanation. (d) Identify one limitation and its effect on the conclusion.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. SE = SD ÷ √n.

  2. Trend: direction, size with units, and spread.

  3. Interpret with pp against 0.05 and the hypothesis; then a limitation and its effect.

Watch out for

  • Dividing the SD by nn instead of n\sqrt{n}.

  • Stating "significant" without the direction of the difference.

Exam tip

Data test habits

  • Determine (about 30%): show the calculation with numbers substituted, round to 2 decimal places unless told otherwise, and give units.
  • Analyse (about 30%): state the trend with numbers ("mean reaction time rose from 217.58 ms to 230.42 ms"), compare spread (SD, error bars), and name a limitation with its effect.
  • Interpret (about 40%): use pp against 0.05, state the conclusion in terms of the hypothesis and the variables, and say how far it can be generalised.

Summary

  • Behavioural neuroscience uses case studies of damage, experiments, correlational studies and treatment trials; each has strengths and limitations.

  • Repeated measures and matched data use a paired tt-test; independent groups an unpaired one. p<0.05p < 0.05 means statistically significant.

  • A correlation, however strong and significant, cannot show cause; a trial without a placebo control cannot rule out expectation.

  • Plasticity helps recovery from brain injury through rerouting, sprouting and reorganisation; it is greater in younger brains and is driven by practice.

  • Psychologists use these findings to assess injuries, plan rehabilitation and develop treatments.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 9 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account