Lesson 2: Localised and distributed brain function
H.M.: what one patient showed about memory
SkillLocalised and distributed function
Worked example
In 1953, to control severe epilepsy, Henry Molaison (known in research as H.M.) had a large part of the medial temporal lobe removed on both sides of his brain, including most of each hippocampus and amygdala. Afterwards his intelligence, language and short-term memory were normal, and he remembered much of his life before the operation. But he could not remember new events or people for more than a few minutes. Over three days he practised tracing a star while looking at it in a mirror; he improved steadily, yet each day said he had never done the task before.
Use H.M.'s case to explain how memory can be viewed as a distributed function.
Step 1: Identify the kinds of memory
Remembering new events is explicit memory. Improving at mirror-tracing is a motor skill, implicit (procedural) memory.
Step 2: Link the loss to the hippocampus
Without his hippocampi he could not encode and consolidate new explicit memories: the hippocampus is needed to form them.
Step 3: Link the intact old memories to the neo-cortex
His older explicit memories survived because, once consolidated, they are stored across the neo-cortex, which was not removed.
Step 4: Link the intact skill to other structures
He still formed implicit memories, because motor skills are formed by the basal ganglia and cerebellum, which were intact.
Step 5: Conclude
No single structure holds "memory": different structures form, store and add emotion to different kinds of memory, so memory is distributed.
The question asks you to explain the view, so the conclusion must say what the case shows about distribution, not just list the structures.
Answer
H.M. lost the ability to form new explicit memories (hippocampus removed) but kept old explicit memories (stored in the neo-cortex) and could still learn a motor skill (implicit memory formed by the basal ganglia and cerebellum). Memory therefore depends on several structures with different roles: it is a distributed function.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Sort the evidence into explicit and implicit memory, old and new.
Match each to the structure removed or spared.
Conclude about distributed function.
Watch out for
Saying the hippocampus stores all memories: his old memories survived without it.
Calling mirror-tracing an explicit memory because he was aware of doing it: the improvement happened without conscious recall.