Lesson 3: Broca's area, Wernicke's area and Geschwind's territory
Locate the damage from two patients' speech
SkillLanguage areas of the brain
Worked example
Two patients are seen after strokes in the left hemisphere.
- Patient X is asked to describe a picture of a family at a beach. She says, slowly and with effort: "Beach… boy… sand… um… water… mum… sit." She follows spoken instructions such as "touch your nose, then your ear" correctly.
- Patient Y says fluently: "Oh yes, the beach, they're all having a lovely forcheck by the thing, and the little one is doing the stuff with the—you know." He cannot follow the same instructions.
(a) Identify the type of aphasia each has and the area most likely damaged. (b) Explain why patient X can understand instructions but patient Y cannot.
Step 1: Patient X
Slow, effortful speech of key words with the small grammar words missing, but understanding intact: Broca's aphasia, damage to Broca's area in the left frontal lobe.
Step 2: Patient Y
Fluent speech with normal rhythm but little meaning and a made-up word ("forcheck"), and poor understanding: Wernicke's aphasia, damage to Wernicke's area in the left temporal lobe.
Step 3: Explain the difference in understanding
Understanding the meaning of spoken words depends on Wernicke's area, which is intact in X and damaged in Y. Broca's area plans and produces speech, so its damage affects X's speaking but not her understanding.
Answer
(a) X: Broca's aphasia, Broca's area (left frontal lobe). Y: Wernicke's aphasia, Wernicke's area (left temporal lobe). (b) Comprehension depends on Wernicke's area, intact in X but damaged in Y; Broca's area is for producing speech.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Is speech fluent or effortful? Is understanding intact?
Effortful with good understanding → Broca's; fluent but meaningless with poor understanding → Wernicke's; good understanding but cannot repeat → arcuate fasciculus.
Watch out for
Labelling Y's fluent speech as Broca's because it is grammatical-sounding.
Naming the lobe without the area, or the area without the hemisphere.