Lesson 9: Prevalence across cultures
Explain a cross-cultural difference in GAD
SkillsPrevalence across culturesGAD and specific phobias
Worked example
The WHO World Mental Health Surveys found the lifetime prevalence of GAD was 5.0% in high-income countries and 1.6% in low-income countries (Ruscio et al., 2017).
Analyse this finding. Calculate how many times higher the high-income prevalence is, and give one possible real explanation and two possible measurement explanations for the difference. (5 marks)
Step 1: Calculate the ratio
, so GAD was about 3.1 times as common (3.4 percentage points higher) in high-income countries.
Step 2: A real explanation
Life in high-income countries may carry risk factors for chronic worry, such as more individual responsibility for success, long working hours and weaker extended-family support, which would mean more people truly have GAD.
Step 3: Measurement explanation 1
Reporting and stigma: people in some low-income countries may be less familiar with anxiety as a health problem, or more ashamed to report it, so fewer cases are counted.
Step 4: Measurement explanation 2
Expression and diagnostic practice: in some cultures anxiety is expressed through bodily complaints or local concepts such as "thinking too much", which an interview built on DSM criteria may not capture.
Step 5: Evaluate
The surveys used the same interview everywhere, which reduces some measurement differences, but the same words can mean different things in different cultures. Checking the interview against assessments by local clinicians would show how much of the gap is real.
Answer
About 3.1 times higher. Real: different risk factors (pressures of life, weaker extended-family support). Measurement: stigma and unfamiliarity reduce reporting; anxiety expressed physically or in local terms is missed by DSM-based interviews. Local validation would show how much is real.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate the ratio or difference.
Give a real explanation and measurement explanations.
Say what evidence would tell them apart.
Watch out for
Giving only measurement explanations, or only real ones. The question asks for both.