Lesson 7: Twin, family and adoption studies
Read IQ correlations between relatives
SkillTwin, family and adoption studies
Worked example
The table gives average correlations between the IQ scores of relatives (Bouchard & McGue 1981).
| Relationship | r |
|---|---|
| Identical (MZ) twins reared together | 0.86 |
| Fraternal (DZ) twins reared together | 0.60 |
| Siblings reared together | 0.47 |
| Siblings reared apart | 0.24 |
(a) Which two correlations show the effect of genes, with the home held the same? What do they suggest? (b) Which two show the effect of the home, with genes held the same? What do they suggest?
Step 1: Find a pair that differs only in genes
MZ and DZ twins reared together both share a home; MZ twins share 100% of their genes, DZ twins 50%.
Step 2: Compare them
. The twins who share more genes are more alike.
Step 3: Find a pair that differs only in the home
Siblings reared together and apart both share 50% of their genes; only the home differs.
Step 4: Compare them
. Siblings raised together are more alike.
Answer
(a) MZ together (0.86) and DZ together (0.60): more genes shared, more similar IQs, which suggests genetic influence. (b) Siblings together (0.47) and apart (0.24): same genes, but sharing a home makes them more alike, which suggests environmental influence.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Find two relationships that differ in only one thing: genes or home.
Compare their correlations and say what the difference suggests.
Watch out for
Comparing MZ together with siblings apart: they differ in both genes and home.
Saying a correlation of 0.86 means 86% of intelligence is genetic.