Lesson 7: Twin, family and adoption studies
Evaluate the conclusion of the Minnesota twins study
SkillsTwin, family and adoption studiesResearch methods in intelligence
Worked example
Bouchard, Lykken, McGue, Segal & Tellegen (1990) found that the WAIS IQs of identical twins reared apart correlated 0.69, and concluded that about 70% of the variation in IQ was associated with genetic variation.
Evaluate this conclusion. (5 marks)
Step 1: State the logic that supports it
MZ twins reared apart share all their genes but not a home, so if their IQs still correlate, the similarity can be put down to genes. Their correlation (0.69) is higher than that of DZ twins raised in the same home (0.60), and because only genes are shared it estimates heritability directly.
Step 2: Add supporting strengths
Testing was intensive and standardised (about 50 hours, including the WAIS), each twin was tested separately by a different examiner, and zygosity was checked biologically.
Step 3: Identify what could inflate the estimate
The twins shared a womb and often months together before separation; some had contact before testing; adoption agencies often placed children in similar homes (selective placement); and the homes were mostly Western and adequately resourced, so environments varied less than in the world at large.
Step 4: Identify sampling limits
Only 48 pairs contributed the WAIS correlation, and many volunteered after media stories, so the sample may overrepresent strikingly similar twins.
Step 5: Judge
The study is strong evidence of a substantial genetic influence on IQ. But "70%" is an estimate for this sample's population and range of environments, probably inflated by shared early environment and selective placement, and it describes variation in a population, not any one person.
Answer
The conclusion is supported by the logic of the design (same genes, different homes), standardised testing and an MZA correlation higher than that of DZ twins raised together. It is weakened by shared prenatal and early environment, contact, selective placement, a narrow range of homes and a small self-selected sample, so 70% is best read as an upper-end estimate for that population, not a fixed property of intelligence.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Explain why the design supports the conclusion.
Name strengths of the method.
Name factors that could inflate or bias the estimate.
Judge how far the conclusion holds, and for whom.
Watch out for
Only describing the study. Evaluate means judging the conclusion against the evidence.
Saying the study proves intelligence is 70% genetic for each person.