Lesson 4: Gardner's multiple intelligences, Goleman's EQ and the uses of IQ
Discuss using IQ alone to select team leaders
SkillsComparing approaches and usesTheories of intelligence
Worked example
A retail company plans to choose its new customer service team leaders using only the applicants' scores on a 30-minute IQ test.
Discuss the significance of using the psychometric approach for this purpose, compared with Goleman's emotional intelligence and Sternberg's triarchic theory. (6 marks)
Step 1: State what the psychometric approach offers
An IQ test is standardised, scored the same way for everyone and highly reliable, and ability scores predict success in job training and performance moderately well. That makes it a fair-seeming, cheap and defensible first measure.
Step 2: State its limitation for this job
It samples mainly analytical, school-type abilities. A team leader in customer service also needs to manage their own frustration, read customers' and staff members' emotions and resolve conflict, which an IQ test does not measure (limited content validity for the job).
Step 3: Bring in Goleman
Goleman's emotional intelligence targets exactly those skills: self-regulation, empathy and social skills. But self-report EQ measures are easy to fake in a job application and overlap with personality, so they should not be used alone either.
Step 4: Bring in Sternberg
Sternberg's practical intelligence (tacit knowledge of how to get things done in a workplace) is relevant too, and could be assessed with realistic scenarios, though such measures are harder to score reliably.
Step 5: Judge
The psychometric approach is significant because it gives a reliable, standardised measure, but on its own it would miss abilities central to the job. A better process combines an ability test with structured assessments of emotional and practical skills, such as interviews and work scenarios.
Answer
IQ testing is significant because it is standardised, reliable and moderately predictive of job performance, but for a team-leader role it misses the emotional (Goleman) and practical (Sternberg) abilities the job needs. Those approaches add relevant abilities but have weaker measures, so the company should combine methods rather than rely on IQ alone.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State the strength of the psychometric approach for the use.
State what it misses for this use.
Compare each other approach: what it adds, and its own weakness.
Finish with a judgement.
Watch out for
Describing each theory without relating it to the job.
Saying EQ "is more important than IQ" without evidence.