Lesson 8: Achievement goal, cognitive evaluation and self-efficacy theories
Compare three theories of motivation for one student
SkillTheories of motivation
Worked example
Lucas took up chess because he enjoyed it. His school then started a ladder that ranks players and gives $20 vouchers to the top three each term. After losing several games to higher-ranked players, Lucas says, "I'm just not good enough to beat them," and has stopped going to chess club.
Compare how the achievement goal, cognitive evaluation and self-efficacy theories explain why Lucas stopped. (6 marks)
Step 1: Achievement goal theory
The ranked ladder creates a performance climate that pushes Lucas towards ego orientation: success means beating others. Losing to higher-ranked players then signals low ability, so, as the theory predicts for ego-oriented people who doubt their ability, he withdraws.
Step 2: Cognitive evaluation theory
Lucas was intrinsically motivated. The vouchers, expected and tied to rank, are likely felt as controlling, shifting his reason for playing to an extrinsic one; losing also gives negative competence information. Both lower intrinsic motivation.
Step 3: Self-efficacy theory
His efficacy expectation is low ("I'm not good enough to beat them"): his recent performance accomplishments were failures, the strongest source of low self-efficacy. His outcome expectation (practice leads to wins) may be fine, but without efficacy he does not act.
Step 4: Similarity
All three are cognitive and all link his quitting to how he interprets his losses and his competence.
Step 5: Differences
They focus on different beliefs: how he defines success (achievement goal), why he plays and whether the rewards feel controlling (cognitive evaluation), and whether he believes he can win (self-efficacy). Only cognitive evaluation theory explains why the vouchers themselves could lower his motivation.
Answer
Achievement goal: the ladder made him ego-oriented, so losing meant low ability and he withdrew. Cognitive evaluation: controlling, expected rewards and negative feedback lowered intrinsic motivation. Self-efficacy: repeated failure lowered his efficacy expectation. All are cognitive and concern competence, but they focus on different beliefs, and only cognitive evaluation explains the effect of the vouchers.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Apply each theory with its own terms and the scenario's details.
State at least one similarity and two differences.