Lesson 3: Designing the emotive stimulus experiment
Design the emotive stimulus experiment
SkillDesigning the heart rate experiment
Worked example
A teacher plans to test whether watching a scary film clip raises heart rate more than watching a toothpaste advertisement, using the 24 students in a Year 11 class.
(a) State the IV and the operationalised DV. (b) Write a two-tailed alternative hypothesis. (c) Recommend a design, with the control it needs. (d) Identify two ethical considerations and how to meet them.
Step 1: Variables
IV: the type of clip, a 3-minute scary film scene (emotive) or a 3-minute toothpaste advertisement (informative). DV: change in heart rate (bpm), the beats counted in the last 60 s of the clip minus the beats counted in 60 s after 5 minutes of quiet rest.
Step 2: Hypothesis
There will be a difference in the mean change in heart rate of Year 11 students when watching the scary clip compared with the toothpaste advertisement.
Two-tailed: a difference, with no direction. It names the population, both conditions and the operationalised DV.
Step 3: Design
Repeated measures: every student watches both clips, so differences in resting heart rate, fitness and sensitivity to horror are controlled. Counterbalance (12 students see the scary clip first, 12 the advertisement first) and rest until heart rate returns to resting between clips, to control order effects.
Step 4: Ethics
Informed consent: students (and, for those under 16, a parent or carer) are told in writing that one clip may be frightening and that heart rate is measured. Protection from harm: an age-appropriate clip with no graphic violence, and students with heart conditions, anxiety or a dislike of horror excluded or allowed to opt out; any student can look away or withdraw (withdrawal rights), and everyone is debriefed.
Answer
IV: type of clip (emotive or informative). DV: change in heart rate (bpm) from 60 s at rest to the last 60 s of the clip. H₁: there will be a difference in the mean change in heart rate between the two clips. Repeated measures, counterbalanced, with rest between clips. Ethics: informed (and parental) consent; protection from harm with an age-appropriate clip, exclusions, withdrawal rights and debriefing.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Operationalise: what exactly is shown, and what exactly is measured, how and when.
Match the design to the main threat: participant variables (repeated measures) or order effects (counterbalancing).
Make each ethical point specific to this study.