Lesson 9: Predicting the effects of localised brain damage
Locate damage from a set of symptoms
SkillsPredicting effects of brain damageLobes and localised functions
Worked example
A 45-year-old woman is struck on the back of the head in a cycling accident. A week later her doctor notes:
- She cannot see objects to her left, with either eye, although her eyes themselves are undamaged.
- She walks unsteadily, overshoots when reaching for a cup, and her speech is slightly slurred, though her words and grammar are normal.
- Her memory, understanding of speech and personality are unchanged.
(a) Identify the two areas most likely damaged, with the division or lobe of each. (b) Justify your answer with the evidence. (c) Explain why you could not be certain from these observations alone, and suggest how the damage could be confirmed.
Step 1: Locate the visual loss
Loss of the left half of what both eyes see, with healthy eyes, points to the visual cortex: the right primary visual cortex, in the right occipital lobe. Each hemisphere processes the opposite half of the visual field.
Damage to one eye would affect only that eye. A loss in both eyes on the same side must be in the brain, behind the point where the pathways from the two eyes meet.
Step 2: Locate the coordination problem
Unsteady walking, overshooting and slurred speech with normal language are problems of coordinating movement: the cerebellum, in the hindbrain. Both are at the back of the head, where she was struck.
Step 3: Use what is spared
Normal words and grammar rule out Broca's and Wernicke's areas; unchanged memory and personality suggest the temporal and frontal lobes were spared.
Step 4: (c) Limits and confirmation
Symptoms are indirect evidence: damage is rarely confined to one area, swelling in the first weeks can cause effects that later fade, and people's brains differ. An MRI scan would show the structure of the damaged areas directly.
Answer
(a) Right primary visual cortex (occipital lobe) and cerebellum (hindbrain). (b) Loss of the left visual field in both eyes means the right visual cortex; unsteadiness, overshooting and slurred speech with normal language mean the cerebellum; both lie at the back of the head, where she was hit, and language, memory and personality areas are spared. (c) Damage may be widespread or temporary and brains differ; an MRI scan would show the damage.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
List each symptom and the function it disrupts.
Map each function to its area; flip sides for vision, movement and sensation.
Use spared abilities to rule areas out.
Check the locations fit the injury, then state the limits and how to confirm.
Watch out for
Naming the left visual cortex for loss of the left visual field.
Naming Broca's area because speech is slurred. Slurring with normal words and grammar is a coordination problem, not aphasia.