Lesson 10: Investigating divided attention and memory: means, SD and the t-test
Interpret an unpaired t-test on divided attention at recall
Skillst-tests and significanceMean, SD and error bars
Worked example
Another class tested divided attention at retrieval. Twenty students learnt the same 20-word list with full attention, and were then randomly allocated to recall it either with full attention or while sorting cards.
| Recall condition | n | Mean words recalled | SD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full attention | 10 | 12.1 | 2.0 |
| Divided attention | 10 | 11.4 | 2.2 |
An unpaired t-test gave , , .
(a) Explain why an unpaired t-test was used. (b) Interpret the result. (c) Explain how the result relates to Craik et al. (1996).
Step 1: Choose the test
Each student recalled in one condition only (independent groups), so the scores are not paired: an unpaired t-test, .
Step 2: Make the decision
is greater than 0.05: the difference of 0.7 words is not significant. Retain the null hypothesis.
Step 3: Conclude
Dividing attention while recalling did not significantly reduce the number of words recalled (mean 11.4, SD 2.2, against 12.1, SD 2.0).
Step 4: Link to Craik et al.
Craik et al. (1996) found that divided attention at retrieval had only a small effect on memory, much smaller than at encoding. The class's result is consistent with this, although a small real effect could have been missed with 10 per group (a type II error).
Answer
(a) Independent groups: each student was in one condition, so the data are unpaired. (b) , so the 0.7-word difference is not significant; retain H₀. (c) Consistent with Craik et al. (1996): divided attention at retrieval has little effect on memory.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Independent groups → unpaired; repeated measures or matched participants → paired.
Compare with 0.05 and state the decision about H₀.
Conclude in words with the means, and relate to the original study.
Watch out for
Saying the result "proves" divided attention has no effect at retrieval.