Lesson 5: Why we sleep: restoration and evolutionary theories
Compare the restoration and evolutionary theories of sleep
SkillWhy we sleep
Worked example
Use the evidence below to compare the restoration and evolutionary theories of sleep.
- After a 92 km ultramarathon, runners slept longer and with more slow-wave sleep for two nights (Shapiro et al. 1981).
- Horses sleep about 2.9 hours a day and lions about 13.5 hours, mostly measured in captivity (Campbell & Tobler 1984; Siegel 2022).
Step 1: State each theory
The restoration theory says sleep lets the body and brain recover and repair what waking uses up. The evolutionary theory says sleep evolved to keep animals safe and save energy when activity is dangerous or unproductive.
Step 2: Link each piece of evidence to a theory
The ultramarathon runners needed more deep sleep after extreme exertion, as restoration predicts. The horse, a grazing prey animal that must eat for most of the day and watch for predators, sleeps little; the lion, a predator with a high-energy diet and few enemies, sleeps a lot, as the evolutionary theory predicts.
Step 3: Similarities
Both theories see sleep as serving survival, and both are supported by evidence. Neither alone explains everything.
Step 4: Differences
The restoration theory explains why sleep loss impairs us and why deep sleep rebounds, whereas it does not explain why species sleep such different amounts or why we sleep at night. The evolutionary theory explains those differences, whereas it does not explain why we suffer without sleep.
A comparison sets the theories side by side on the same points, rather than describing each in turn.
Answer
Both theories explain sleep as aiding survival. The restoration theory (sleep repairs and replenishes) explains the runners' extra deep sleep and the effects of deprivation but not differences between species; the evolutionary theory (sleep keeps animals safe and saves energy) explains why horses sleep little and lions a lot but not why deprivation harms us.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State each theory in one sentence.
Link each piece of evidence to the theory it supports, with the reason.
Give similarities, then differences point by point, with "whereas".
Watch out for
Describing the two theories in separate paragraphs with no comparison.
Using evidence without saying which theory it supports and why.