Lesson 8: Sleep disorders and their treatment
Compare narcolepsy and sleep apnoea
SkillSleep disorders and treatments
Worked example
Narcolepsy and obstructive sleep apnoea both cause excessive daytime sleepiness. Compare the two disorders and their treatments.
Step 1: A similarity
Both cause excessive daytime sleepiness that affects concentration and safety (for example when driving), and both are diagnosed with a sleep study.
Step 2: The cause of the sleepiness
In sleep apnoea, the airway repeatedly collapses during sleep, breathing stops for 10 seconds or more, and the person wakes briefly many times, so sleep is broken and unrefreshing. In narcolepsy, the brain cannot keep wakefulness stable (linked to the loss of wake-promoting neurons in the hypothalamus), so sleep intrudes into the day whatever the night's sleep was like.
Step 3: Features
Sleep apnoea brings loud snoring, gasping and morning headaches; narcolepsy brings sudden sleep attacks, REM within minutes of falling asleep, and often cataplexy.
Step 4: Treatments
Sleep apnoea is treated by keeping the airway open (CPAP, weight loss, sleeping on the side); narcolepsy has no cure and is managed with scheduled naps, regular sleep and medication.
Answer
Both cause daytime sleepiness, are diagnosed by sleep studies and affect safety. In sleep apnoea the sleepiness comes from sleep broken by repeated pauses in breathing (snoring, gasping), treated with CPAP; in narcolepsy it comes from unstable control of wakefulness (sleep attacks, early REM, cataplexy), managed with naps and medication.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Start with a similarity.
Compare the cause, the features and the treatment, point by point.
Watch out for
Writing two separate descriptions without linking words such as "whereas" or "both".