Lesson 4: Imprinting and contact comfort
Explain how Harlow challenged earlier ideas
SkillsAttachment researchResearch methods and ethics
Worked example
Explain how Harlow & Zimmermann's (1958) research with infant rhesus monkeys challenged the learning theory view of attachment, and evaluate the research on one ethical and one methodological point.
Step 1: State the learning theory view
Learning theory ("cupboard love") held that an infant becomes attached to whoever feeds them, because the caregiver is associated with food.
Step 2: Describe the procedure
Infant monkeys were raised with a bare wire surrogate mother and a soft cloth surrogate. For some, only the wire mother held a feeding bottle.
Step 3: Describe the findings
Even when only the wire mother gave milk, the infants spent most of their time on the cloth mother, ran to her when frightened, and used her as a base for exploring.
Step 4: State the challenge
If food were the basis of attachment, the infants fed by the wire mother would have preferred it. They didn't, so contact comfort, not food, was the basis of the bond.
Step 5: Evaluate ethically
The infants were separated from their mothers and deliberately frightened, causing distress and lasting social harm. Under today's animal research codes, the harm would not be justified.
Step 6: Evaluate methodologically
Rhesus monkeys are not humans, and surrogate mothers are unlike real caregivers, so generalising to human infants is limited.
Answer
Infants preferred the cloth mother even when the wire mother fed them, showing that contact comfort, not food, underlies attachment, which challenged learning theory. Ethically, the infants suffered distress and lasting harm; methodologically, results from monkeys with surrogates may not generalise to human infants.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State the earlier view.
Describe the procedure and the key result.
Show why the result contradicts the earlier view.
Evaluate with one ethical and one methodological point.
Watch out for
Saying the monkeys preferred the cloth mother "because it fed them". The point is that they preferred it even when it didn't.