Lesson 2: Plasticity, environments and critical periods
Classify periods as critical or sensitive
SkillNeural plasticity
Worked example
For each case, decide whether it shows a critical period or a sensitive period, and justify your answer.
(a) Kittens raised with one eye kept closed for their first three months never develop normal vision through that eye, but closing one eye of an adult cat for the same time has little effect.
(b) A girl who moved from Japan to Brisbane at age 12 learnt to speak English fluently, though with a noticeable accent, while her younger brother, who arrived at age 4, sounds like a native speaker.
Step 1: Recall the difference
A critical period is a fixed window when an experience must occur; missing it causes lasting, often permanent, effects. A sensitive period is a time when learning is easiest, but it can still happen later.
Step 2: (a) Apply it to the kittens
Vision through the closed eye never develops normally, and only deprivation during the early window has this effect. This is a critical period.
Step 3: (b) Apply it to language
The girl did learn English fluently at 12, so the window had not closed, but her brother, who started earlier, learnt the sound system more completely. This is a sensitive period.
Answer
(a) Critical period: missing visual experience in the early window causes a permanent effect that the same experience later does not. (b) Sensitive period: language can still be learnt at 12, but is learnt most completely when started early.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Ask: can the ability still develop if the experience comes late?
No (or not normally) → critical period. Yes, but less easily → sensitive period.
Watch out for
Calling any age effect a critical period. If learning is still possible later, it is a sensitive period.