Lesson 9: Evidence, accelerators and the Big Bang
How the antineutrino was first detected
SkillsEvidence and discoveryConservation in reactionsElementary particles and antiparticles
Worked example
In 1956 Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines placed tanks of water near a nuclear reactor, which emits huge numbers of electron antineutrinos. They looked for the reaction .
(a) Show that this reaction conserves charge, baryon number and lepton number.
(b) The positron quickly annihilates with an electron, producing two gamma photons. Calculate the energy of each photon in MeV, assuming both particles are at rest. ()
(c) A few microseconds later, the neutron is captured by a nucleus, which emits another gamma ray. Explain why detecting this sequence of gamma rays was convincing evidence for antineutrinos.
Step 1: Conservation
: and . : and . : and . All conserved.
Step 2: Photon energy
Each photon carries one particle's rest energy:
Momentum is zero before, so two equal photons go in opposite directions and share the total energy equally.
Step 3: Why the sequence is convincing
A pair of photons is the fingerprint of a positron, and a delayed gamma ray is the fingerprint of a neutron. Background radiation rarely produces both, in that order, a few microseconds apart. The signal also dropped when the reactor was switched off, linking it to the reactor's antineutrinos.
Answer
(a) : ; : ; : . (b) About each. (c) The delayed coincidence of positron annihilation photons followed by a neutron-capture gamma ray is the unique signature of the reaction, and it depended on the reactor being on.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check conservation with a line for each law.
Annihilation at rest: each photon has .
Evidence: identify the signature, rule out background, look for dependence on the source.