Lesson 6: Harmonics on strings, natural frequency and resonance
Why a crowd made a footbridge sway
SkillNatural frequency and resonance
Worked example
A new footbridge can sway from side to side with a natural frequency of . People walk at about 2 steps per second, and with each pair of steps (left foot, then right foot) a walker pushes the bridge sideways once each way. On opening day, a large crowd made the bridge sway so much that it was closed.
(a) Explain why the bridge swayed so strongly.
(b) Engineers proposed two fixes: (i) limit the number of people allowed on the bridge, or (ii) fit dampers that absorb energy from the sideways motion. Evaluate the two fixes.
Step 1: Find the driving frequency
Each walker pushes sideways once per pair of steps: push cycle per second. The driving frequency is .
Step 2: Compare with the natural frequency
The driving frequency equals the bridge's natural frequency of sideways sway, , so the bridge resonates.
Step 3: Explain the large amplitude
At resonance, the pushes stay in step with the bridge's motion, so each push does positive work and adds energy every cycle. Energy is transferred to the bridge very efficiently, and the amplitude builds until the energy lost each cycle equals the energy supplied. Worse, people on a swaying bridge instinctively fall into step with the sway, so more of them push in phase.
Away from resonance, pushes are sometimes with the motion and sometimes against it, so the energy put in largely cancels out.
Step 4: Evaluate fix (i)
Fewer people means a smaller total driving force and less energy added per cycle, so the sway is smaller. But the driving frequency still matches the natural frequency, so the bridge still resonates, and the bridge can no longer carry the crowds it was built for. It reduces the problem without removing its cause.
Step 5: Evaluate fix (ii)
Dampers remove energy from the motion every cycle, so the amplitude stays small even when the bridge is driven at resonance, and the bridge stays fully usable. This tackles the problem directly and is the better fix. (Making the bridge stiffer to move its natural frequency well away from would also work.)
Answer
(a) The walkers' sideways driving frequency, , equals the bridge's natural frequency, so the bridge resonates: energy is transferred efficiently every cycle and the amplitude builds up. (b) Limiting numbers reduces the energy input but leaves the bridge resonating and less useful; dampers remove energy each cycle so the sway stays small at full capacity, which makes them the better fix.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify the driving frequency and the natural frequency.
If they match, explain resonance in terms of efficient energy transfer.
Judge each fix by whether it changes the frequency match or the energy balance, and at what cost.
Watch out for
Saying "resonance creates energy". The energy comes from the walkers; resonance transfers it efficiently.
Using the step frequency (2 Hz) as the driving frequency for the sideways sway.