Lesson 2: What holds a nucleus together
Explain why heavy nuclei need extra neutrons
SkillNuclear forces and stability
Worked example
Stable carbon-12 has 6 protons and 6 neutrons, but stable lead-208 has 82 protons and 126 neutrons.
Explain this difference in terms of the forces acting between the particles in the nucleus. (4 marks)
Step 1: Name the repulsive force and its range
Protons are positively charged, so every proton repels every other proton electrostatically. This force acts across the whole nucleus.
The first mark is for recognising the source of instability.
Step 2: Name the attractive force and its range
The strong nuclear force attracts all nucleons (protons and neutrons) but acts only over about m, so each nucleon is held only by its nearest neighbours.
Step 3: Compare the small and large nucleus
In carbon-12 every nucleon is close to every other, so the strong force easily outweighs the repulsion of only 6 protons, and equal numbers are stable. In lead-208, each proton is repelled by 81 others across the nucleus but attracted by only its neighbours, so the repulsion grows faster than the attraction.
Step 4: Explain the role of neutrons
Neutrons add strong-force attraction without adding electrostatic repulsion. A large nucleus therefore needs a much higher ratio of neutrons to protons, about for lead-208, to be stable.
Answer
Electrostatic repulsion acts between all protons across the nucleus, but the strong force only acts between neighbouring nucleons. In a large nucleus the repulsion grows faster than the attraction, so extra neutrons (which add attraction without repulsion) are needed: lead-208 has , whereas small carbon-12 is stable with .
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe the electrostatic force (repulsive, protons only, long range).
Describe the strong force (attractive, all nucleons, very short range).
Compare how each grows as the nucleus gets bigger.
Link to the neutron-to-proton ratio.
Watch out for
Saying neutrons "cancel" the protons' charge. Neutrons are neutral; they help only through the strong force.
Forgetting to mention the short range of the strong force, which is the key to the argument.