Lesson 5 of 8 · 16 min
The second derivative test
Classify stationary points as local maxima or minima from the sign of the second derivative, and fall back on the first derivative test when the second derivative is zero.
What you will be able to do
- Use the sign of at a stationary point to decide whether it is a local maximum or a local minimum.
- Recognise when the test fails () and use a sign table of instead.
- Justify the nature of a stationary point in writing, the way the exam expects.
In Unit 2 you decided the nature of a stationary point by checking the sign of either side of it. That works, but it needs two extra calculations and some care choosing test points. Concavity gives a quicker route.
At a stationary point the tangent is horizontal. If the curve is concave up there, it bends up away from that tangent on both sides: the point is a minimum. If it is concave down, it bends down on both sides: a maximum.
For any , has turning points at , and (the dashed line). At the left turning point is negative: a maximum. At the right one is positive: a minimum. What happens when ?
Key idea
The second derivative test
Suppose .
- If , the graph is concave down at : local maximum.
- If , the graph is concave up at : local minimum.
- If , the test gives no conclusion. Use the first derivative test.
Worked example
Classify the stationary points of
Determine the coordinates of the stationary points of , and use the second derivative test to determine their nature.
Step 1: Find the first derivative and solve f′(x) = 0
, so or .
Step 2: Find the y-coordinates
Step 3: Find the second derivative
Step 4: Apply the test at x = 1
, so the graph is concave down: a local maximum.
Step 5: Apply the test at x = 2
, so the graph is concave up: a local minimum.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
is a local maximum, since . is a local minimum, since .
Method
Solve and find the -coordinates.
Evaluate at each stationary point.
Negative: maximum. Positive: minimum. Zero: use a sign table.
Watch out for
Reversing the test. Negative second derivative means concave down, which is a maximum.
Substituting into for the test: by definition, so it tells you nothing.
has a stationary point at . Use the second derivative test to determine its nature.
First derivative test
Find the sign of just left and right of .
- then : local maximum
- then : local minimum
- same sign both sides: stationary point of inflection
Always works, but needs two evaluations.
Second derivative test
Find the sign of .
- : local maximum
- : local minimum
- : no conclusion
One evaluation, but you need , and it can fail.
When the test fails. If , the stationary point could be anything. All three of (a minimum), (a maximum) and (a stationary point of inflection) have and . You have to go back to the sign of .
Worked example
When the second derivative test fails
Determine the nature of each stationary point of .
Step 1: Find the stationary points
, so or .
and .
Step 2: Find the second derivative
Step 3: Test x = 3
, so is a local minimum.
Step 4: Test x = 0
, so the second derivative test gives no conclusion.
A zero second derivative is consistent with a maximum, a minimum or a stationary point of inflection.
Step 5: Use the first derivative test at x = 0
. Near , and , so on both sides.
and .
Step 6: Conclude
The graph decreases on both sides of , so is a stationary point of inflection.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
is a local minimum (). At , , so the second derivative test fails; the first derivative test shows on both sides, so is a stationary point of inflection.
Method
Try the second derivative test first.
If , check the sign of either side of .
Same sign both sides: stationary point of inflection.
Watch out for
Concluding "point of inflection" just because . You must show the change of concavity, or use the first derivative test.
Choosing test points beyond another stationary point, such as when testing .
At a stationary point of a function , , just to the left of , and just to the right. What is the nature of the stationary point?
Exam tip
Writing a justification
A full-marks justification names the test, gives the value, and states the conclusion:
", so by the second derivative test, is a local maximum."
Writing only "maximum" or " is negative" usually loses the mark.
Common mistake
Negative means maximum
Students often reverse the test. Picture : and its vertex is a maximum. Negative second derivative, cap shape, maximum.
Summary
At a stationary point : gives a local maximum; gives a local minimum.
If , the second derivative test fails. Use the sign of either side.
, and all have but different kinds of stationary point.
In a justification, name the test, show the value of and its sign, and state the conclusion with coordinates.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.