Lesson 8: Modelling and solving probability problems
How many smoke alarms?
SkillsModelling with probabilityIndependent eventsComplement and addition rules
Worked example
Each smoke alarm in a house works when needed with probability 0.85, independently of the other alarms.
(a) Find the probability that at least one of two alarms works.
(b) Find the smallest number of alarms needed so that the probability that at least one works is at least 0.999.
(c) Comment on the assumption that the alarms work independently.
Step 1: Use the complement for (a)
Each alarm fails with probability . By independence, both fail with probability , so .
Step 2: Write the condition for (b)
With alarms, . We need , that is, .
Step 3: Test values of
, which is more than 0.001. , which is less than 0.001.
Powers of 0.15 get smaller as grows, so the first that works is the smallest. A calculator table or spreadsheet does this quickly.
Step 4: Conclude
4 alarms are needed: , but 3 alarms give only .
Step 5: Evaluate the assumption for (c)
Alarms in the same house might fail together: they could share a power circuit, have flat batteries if nobody tests them, or come from the same faulty batch. If failures are linked, the chance that all of them fail is higher than the model says, so the real reliability is lower than 0.9995.
Answer
(a) 0.9775 (b) 4 alarms (c) Independence may not hold, because alarms can share causes of failure; then the model overstates the reliability.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
For independent failures, is a product of the failure probabilities.
For "smallest ", test values (by hand or with a table) until the condition is first met.
Comment on whether independence is realistic.
Watch out for
Using , the probability that all the alarms work, instead of the complement of all failing.
Rounding up to 0.999 and choosing 3 alarms.