Lesson 8: Modelling and solving probability problems
How reliable is a positive test?
SkillsModelling with probabilityTree diagrams and the multiplication ruleConditional probability
Worked example
A screening test for a medical condition is used in a population where 2% of people have the condition. If a person has the condition, the probability that the test is positive is 0.95. If a person does not have the condition, the probability that the test is positive is 0.08.
(a) Find the probability that a randomly chosen person tests positive.
(b) A person tests positive. Find the probability that they have the condition, correct to three decimal places.
(c) Comment on what this means for a person who receives a positive result.
Step 1: Name the events and write what you know
Let be "has the condition" and be "tests positive". Then , and .
Step 2: Draw the tree
First stage: 0.02, 0.98. After : 0.95, 0.05. After : 0.08, 0.92.
The given test probabilities are conditional on whether the person has the condition, so condition status goes first.
Step 3: Multiply along the two positive paths
and .
Step 4: Add them for (a)
Step 5: Reverse the condition for (b)
Step 6: Check with a population of 10,000
About 200 people have the condition and 190 of them test positive. About 9800 don't, and 784 of them test positive. Of the positives, have the condition.
Imagining a large round population is a quick, reliable check on a conditional probability.
Step 7: Interpret for (c)
Only about 1 in 5 positive results comes from a person with the condition. Because the condition is rare, most positives are false positives from the large group without it, so a positive screening result should be followed by a more accurate diagnostic test.
Answer
(a) (b) (c) About 80% of positive results are false positives, so a positive result means "test again", not a diagnosis.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Define events and identify which given probabilities are conditional.
Tree: condition first, then test result.
Add the paths for , then reverse with .
Interpret in context and check with a round-number population.
Watch out for
Answering 0.95, which is , not .
Forgetting the false-positive path when finding .