Lesson 7: Choosing the right model
Perpetuity or a 25-year pension?
SkillsChoosing the right modelPerpetuity payment and rate
Worked example
Tom retires with $500 000, invested at 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly. He can take either:
- Option 1: a perpetuity, paid at the end of each month, or
- Option 2: a pension paid at the end of each month for 25 years, after which the fund is empty.
Calculate the monthly payment for each option and compare them.
Step 1: Option 1, the perpetuity
, so a month.
Step 2: Option 2, a present value annuity
and :
a month.
A pension that runs out after a fixed term is a present value annuity (Topic 1).
Step 3: Compare the payments
Option 2 pays more each month. Over 25 years it pays , against from Option 1.
Step 4: Compare what is left
After 25 years, Option 2 has nothing left. Option 1 still has the full $500 000, and keeps paying $2000 a month for as long as Tom lives, then passes to his estate.
Answer
Option 1 pays $2000 a month forever; Option 2 pays $2864.98 a month but stops after 25 years. Option 2 gives a higher income; Option 1 never runs out and keeps the $500 000 intact.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Perpetuity: .
Fixed-term pension: solve for .
Compare the payment and what remains at the end.
Watch out for
Using the future value formula for the pension: Tom is drawing money out, not saving.