Lesson 4: Opening balances, time to a goal and comparing plans
Monthly or quarterly saving?
SkillsPlanning and comparing savingsFuture value of an annuityTotal payments and interest
Worked example
Grace can save $4800 a year for 10 years. She is choosing between two accounts:
- Account A: $400 at the end of every month, 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly.
- Account B: $1200 at the end of every quarter, 4.8% p.a. compounded quarterly.
Evaluate the two plans and recommend one, with reasons.
Step 1: Account A
, :
Step 2: Account B
, :
Step 3: Compare like with like
Both plans deposit . Interest: A earns ; B earns . A is ahead by .
Same total deposited, same nominal rate and same term, so the difference is entirely due to timing and compounding.
Step 4: Explain why
In Account A, money goes in sooner: $400 is already earning interest at the end of month 1, while Account B waits until the end of month 3. A's interest is also compounded monthly, a slightly higher effective rate.
Step 5: Recommend, with a limitation
Account A gives $306.42 more over 10 years, so it is the better choice, provided Grace's income lets her deposit monthly. The difference is small (about 0.5% of the final balance), so fees, flexibility or a change in rates could easily matter more.
Answer
Account A grows to $61 452.78 and Account B to $61 146.36. Recommend A: it earns $306.42 more for the same $48 000 deposited, because deposits start earning sooner and interest compounds more often.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate the future value of each plan with its own i and n.
Compare the same quantity: final balance or interest earned.
State the difference, explain it in context, and note a limitation.
Watch out for
Using for the quarterly account.
Recommending without giving the dollar difference or a reason.