Lesson 4 of 7 · 15 min
The effective annual rate — comparing offers fairly
Calculate the effective annual rate with and use it to compare loans and investments that compound daily, monthly, quarterly or six-monthly.
What you will be able to do
- Explain why more frequent compounding gives more interest at the same nominal rate.
- Calculate the effective annual rate, .
- Use effective annual rates to choose the better investment or the cheaper loan.
- Describe the effect of the interest rate and the compounding period on the total amount.
Bank A offers 12% p.a. compounded annually. Bank B offers 12% p.a. compounded monthly. Same rate — but they don't pay the same. Bank B adds 1% every month, and from the second month on that 1% is earned on a slightly bigger balance. By the end of the year, $1 has grown to , so Bank B really pays 12.68% over the year.
That 12.68% is the effective annual rate. The advertised 12% is the nominal rate.
After 10 years, monthly compounding gives $33 003.87 and annual compounding gives $31 058.48. Try daily compounding (365): it adds only a little more than monthly. Then lower the rate to 4% — at low rates the compounding period matters even less.
Definition
Effective annual rate of interest
- is the interest rate per compounding period, as a decimal
- is the number of compounding periods per year
Multiply by 100 for a percentage. It is the rate that, compounded once a year, would give the same interest. The formula is in the QCAA formula book.
Find the effective annual rate for 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly, as a percentage correct to two decimal places.
| Compounded | Effective annual rate | $10 000 after 10 years | |
|---|---|---|---|
| annually | 1 | 6.00% | $17 908.48 |
| six-monthly | 2 | 6.09% | $18 061.11 |
| quarterly | 4 | 6.14% | $18 140.18 |
| monthly | 12 | 6.17% | $18 193.97 |
| weekly | 52 | 6.18% | $18 214.89 |
| daily | 365 | 6.18% | $18 220.29 |
Key idea
What changes the total amount
- More frequent compounding raises the effective rate and the total amount — but by less and less. Going from annual to monthly matters; going from weekly to daily barely does.
- A higher interest rate raises the total far more. In the table, every option at 6% ends below $18 300, but 7% compounded annually reaches $19 671.51.
- A longer term raises the total most of all, because the growth compounds.
Worked example
Choosing the best savings account
Three banks offer savings accounts:
- Bank A: 5.20% p.a. compounded daily
- Bank B: 5.25% p.a. compounded quarterly
- Bank C: 5.32% p.a. compounded annually
Use effective annual rates to decide which account earns the most interest.
Step 1: Bank A
, :
Step 2: Bank B
, :
Step 3: Bank C
Annual compounding: , the same as the nominal rate.
With one compounding period a year there is no interest on interest within the year.
Step 4: Decide
Bank B has the highest effective annual rate, 5.35%, so it earns the most interest.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Bank B (5.35% effective) beats Bank A (5.34%) and Bank C (5.32%), so it earns the most.
Method
For each option, find per period and .
Calculate to at least two decimal places as a percentage.
Choose the highest for an investment, the lowest for a loan.
Watch out for
Choosing Bank C because 5.32% is the biggest advertised rate.
Choosing Bank A because daily compounding "always wins" — it only wins at the same nominal rate.
A fund credits interest of 1.5% per quarter. Find its effective annual rate, as a percentage correct to two decimal places.
Tip
Investments and loans
For an investment, choose the highest effective annual rate — you earn more. For a loan, choose the lowest — you pay less. Compare effective rates, never nominal rates with different compounding periods.
Tama is choosing a personal loan. Lender P charges 7.4% p.a. compounded monthly. Lender Q charges 7.5% p.a. compounded six-monthly. Which statement is correct?
Common mistake
Slips with the effective rate
- Using the annual rate as : for 4.8% p.a. compounded monthly, , not .
- Forgetting to subtract 1: means 4.91%, not 104.91%.
- Comparing nominal rates when the compounding periods differ.
Exam tip
In the exam
For a "compare" or "which is better" question, calculate the effective rate of every option to at least two decimal places, then write a conclusion that uses the numbers: "Account B is the better investment because its effective annual rate (5.35%) is the highest." If two effective rates are equal to two decimal places, give more places or compare the total amounts.
Summary
, with the rate per period and the periods per year.
The effective rate equals the nominal rate only for annual compounding; otherwise it is higher.
More frequent compounding adds interest, with diminishing returns; a higher rate or a longer term adds much more.
Compare offers by effective rate: highest for an investment, lowest for a loan.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.