Lesson 7: Exponential models: populations and diminishing value
When does diminishing value overtake straight-line?
SkillsDiminishing-value depreciationLinear growth and decay modelsWhen is a target reached?
Worked example
A Toowoomba engineering firm buys a $60 000 machine. Its accountant can depreciate it by either
- Method A: straight-line, $7500 per year, or
- Method B: diminishing value, 20% per year.
After how many years will the book value under Method B first be greater than under Method A? Justify your answer, and comment on what happens after that.
Step 1: Model each method
After years, Method A gives (arithmetic, ) and Method B gives (geometric, ).
Step 2: Think about the shape before calculating
B loses $12 000 in year 1 (more than A's $7500), but its yearly loss shrinks while A's stays the same. So B starts lower and must eventually be higher.
Knowing a crossover must exist tells you a table will find it.
Step 3: Tabulate both values
Years, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 A ($) 52 500 45 000 37 500 30 000 22 500 15 000 7500 B ($) 48 000 38 400 30 720 24 576 19 660.80 15 728.64 12 582.91 Step 4: Identify the crossover
After 5 years B is lower ($19 660.80 < $22 500); after 6 years B is higher ($15 728.64 > $15 000).
Step 5: Comment on the long run
After 8 years Method A reaches $0, while under Method B the machine keeps some value (it is never fully written off). From year 6 on, B always gives the higher value.
Answer
After 6 years: Method B gives $15 728.64 and Method A gives $15 000. Before that, Method B gives the lower value; from then on it gives the higher value, and Method A reaches $0 after 8 years.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Write the value after years for each method.
Tabulate both side by side (technology table mode or a spreadsheet).
Find the first year the order changes, quote both values, and conclude in context.
Watch out for
Giving 5 years: B is still below A after 5 years.
Using instead of .