Lesson 6: Association and causation
Explain an association with a confounding variable
SkillsNon-causal explanationsAssociation and causation
Worked example
At a Townsville primary school, the shoe size and reading score of 60 students from Years 1 to 6 have a strong positive association, . A parent suggests that buying children bigger shoes would improve their reading. Explain why this conclusion is not justified, and give a possible non-causal explanation for the association.
Step 1: Acknowledge the association
There is a strong positive linear association (): students with larger shoe sizes tend to have higher reading scores.
Step 2: State the principle
An association does not necessarily mean that one variable causes the other.
Step 3: Identify a confounding variable
Age (or year level). Older students have bigger feet, and older students have had more years of reading practice, so they read better.
A good non-causal explanation names a variable and says how it is linked to both variables in the association.
Step 4: Conclude
Age explains the association, so changing shoe size would not change reading scores. The parent's conclusion is not justified.
Answer
Association does not imply causation. Age is a confounding variable: older children have both bigger feet and better reading, which produces the association.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe the association and quote the statistic.
State that association does not necessarily imply causation.
Name a specific confounding variable and explain its link to both variables.
Watch out for
Saying "there could be another variable" without naming and explaining one.