Lesson 6: Association and causation
Association and causation in a two-way table
SkillsAssociation and causationNon-causal explanations
Worked example
A survey of 400 Queensland adults asked whether they own a dog and whether they exercise at least three times a week.
| Exercise 3+ times a week | Don't | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Own a dog | 93 | 57 | 150 |
| Don't own a dog | 103 | 147 | 250 |
| Total | 196 | 204 | 400 |
A pet-food company claims: "Owning a dog makes you exercise more." Use percentages to describe the association, then evaluate the claim.
Step 1: Percentage within the explanatory variable
Dog ownership is explanatory, so percentage the rows: of dog owners exercise regularly, compared with of non-owners.
Step 2: Describe the association
The percentages differ substantially (62% versus 41.2%), so there is an association: dog owners are more likely to exercise regularly.
Step 3: Association is not causation
This is a survey, not an experiment, so it shows association only.
Step 4: Give non-causal explanations
Another variable could explain it. People who are already active are more likely to choose to own a dog; people with houses and yards (or more free time) may be more likely both to own a dog and to exercise.
Step 5: Evaluate the claim
The data supports an association but not the claim that owning a dog causes more exercise. That would need a study that controls for these other variables, such as an experiment.
Answer
62% of dog owners exercise regularly versus 41.2% of non-owners, so there is an association. But the survey can't show cause: active people may be more likely to get a dog, and other variables (housing, free time) may affect both. The claim is not justified by this data.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate percentages within each category of the explanatory variable.
Compare them to describe the association.
State that association does not imply causation and give specific non-causal explanations.
Conclude on the claim.
Watch out for
Comparing counts (93 versus 103) instead of percentages.
Accepting the claim because the difference in percentages is large.