Lesson 11: Automatic stabilisers and discretionary fiscal policy
Fiscal policy in the 2020 recession, applied with a diagram
SkillsStabilisers and discretionary policyShifting AD and AS
Worked example
Using the data and an AD–AS diagram, analyse the roles of automatic stabilisers and discretionary fiscal policy in Australia's 2020 recession.
| Indicator | Value |
|---|---|
| Real GDP growth, June quarter 2020 (on the previous quarter) | −6.8% |
| Unemployment rate, March 2020 → July 2020 | 5.2% → 7.4% |
| Underlying cash balance, 2018–19 | about 0.0% of GDP |
| Underlying cash balance, 2020–21 | −6.4% of GDP (a deficit of $134.2 billion) |
| Underlying cash balance, 2022–23 | +0.9% of GDP (a surplus of $22.1 billion) |
Step 1: The shock
Lockdowns cut household consumption and business investment, shifting AD left: real GDP fell 6.8% in the June quarter 2020 and unemployment rose from 5.2% to 7.4%, opening a large recessionary gap.
Step 2: Automatic stabilisers
As incomes and profits fell, income and company tax receipts fell, and more people received JobSeeker. Without any decision, these changes pushed the budget towards deficit and limited the fall in disposable income, so AD fell less than it otherwise would have.
Step 3: Discretionary policy
The government added large discretionary stimulus: JobKeeper wage subsidies kept workers attached to their employers and their incomes up, and temporary increases to payments supported consumption. This shifted AD right (the diagram), towards potential output.
Step 4: The budget data
The underlying cash balance moved from about balance in 2018–19 to a deficit of 6.4% of GDP in 2020–21: partly cyclical (the stabilisers) and partly discretionary (the stimulus). As the economy recovered and the temporary measures ended, it returned to a surplus of 0.9% of GDP in 2022–23, showing much of the deficit was cyclical and temporary rather than structural.
Step 5: Link to the objectives
By supporting AD, fiscal policy limited cyclical unemployment and the loss of output. Unemployment fell back to 5.0% by June 2021, faster than after earlier recessions, though the stimulus also added to the demand pressure behind the 2022 rise in inflation.
Answer
The shock shifted AD left. Automatic stabilisers (falling tax receipts, rising JobSeeker) cushioned the fall; discretionary policy such as JobKeeper shifted AD back right. The deficit of 6.4% of GDP in 2020–21 was largely cyclical and temporary, as the return to surplus in 2022–23 shows.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Discretionary stimulus shifts AD right, towards potential output.
Method
Describe the shock as a shift of AD, with data.
Explain the automatic stabilisers (no decision) and the discretionary measures (decisions) separately.
Use the budget balance to separate cyclical from structural effects.
Link the outcome to the objectives.
Watch out for
Treating the whole deficit as discretionary stimulus. Part of it was the automatic stabilisers.
Drawing the diagram without explaining it in words, or explaining without a diagram when one is asked for.