Lesson 1 of 10 · 15 min
Why governments manage the economy
Explain why governments make economic policy: to improve efficiency and equity while weighing the trade-offs, to stabilise the economic cycle, and to reach Australia’s growth, wellbeing and stability objectives.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how economic policy can improve efficiency and equity.
- Explain the trade-offs a government faces between efficiency and equity, between objectives, and between now and the future.
- Explain why a government tries to stabilise the economic cycle.
- Describe the objectives economic policy aims at: sustainable economic growth, economic prosperity and wellbeing, internal stability and external stability.
In 2020–21 the federal budget recorded an underlying cash deficit of 6.4% of GDP, the largest since the series began in 1970–71. Two years later, in 2022–23, it recorded a surplus of 0.9% of GDP. Neither happened by accident. Each was partly the result of choices about taxing, spending and borrowing, made to steer the economy through a pandemic and then a burst of inflation.
Why should a government try to steer the economy at all? Markets do most of the work of deciding what is produced, how and for whom. This lesson sets out the rationale for economic policy: the reasons a government steps in, and the goals it aims at.
Definition
Economic policy
Economic policy is a government's (or its central bank's) deliberate use of its tools, such as taxes, spending, interest rates and regulation, to change how the economy performs. Macroeconomic policy (fiscal and monetary) works on the economy as a whole; microeconomic policy works on particular markets and industries.
Reason 1: efficiency
You met three kinds of efficiency in Units 1 and 2:
- Allocative efficiency: resources go to producing the mix of goods and services society values most.
- Productive (technical) efficiency: goods are produced at the lowest possible cost.
- Dynamic efficiency: firms and the economy adapt and innovate over time.
Markets fail when they under-provide public goods (roads, defence), ignore externalities (pollution, the benefits of research), under-supply merit goods (education, health care) or are dominated by a few firms. Policy that corrects these failures, through taxes, subsidies, regulation, competition law or direct provision, moves the economy closer to efficiency, so more is produced from the same scarce resources.
Reason 2: equity
A market economy rewards people for the resources they own and the work they can do. It does not guarantee that the result is fair. Equity is about fairness, which is not the same as equality:
- Vertical equity: people with greater capacity to pay contribute more (a progressive income tax).
- Horizontal equity: people in the same circumstances are treated the same way.
Governments pursue equity with progressive taxes, transfer payments such as the Age Pension and JobSeeker Payment, and services such as Medicare and public schools that everyone can use whatever their income.
Two workers each earn $70 000 a year, one as a nurse and one as a builder. Under the income tax scale they pay the same tax. Which idea does this illustrate?
Trade-offs
Every policy choice gives something up. That is opportunity cost again, applied to a whole economy.
- Efficiency against equity. A higher top tax rate funds more transfers (equity) but can weaken the incentive to work, save and invest (efficiency). A generous unemployment payment protects people but, if badly designed, can slow the move back to work.
- One objective against another. Stimulating demand to cut unemployment can push inflation up; raising interest rates to curb inflation can cost jobs. The short-run Phillips curve from Topic 2 is this trade-off.
- Now against later (an intertemporal trade-off). Borrowing to support spending today adds to public debt that must be serviced later; spending on infrastructure or training costs now and pays off over decades.
Key idea
Policy is a choice among trade-offs
There is rarely a policy that is best on every count. Good economic reasoning names what a policy gains, what it costs, and who bears each, then judges whether the gain is worth the cost. That is what evaluate asks of you.
Real GDP fluctuates around its trend. Stabilisation policy tries to make the peaks lower and the troughs shallower.
Reason 3: stabilising the economic cycle
Left alone, spending rises and falls in waves. In a contraction firms cut output and jobs, and cyclical unemployment rises; incomes are lost that are never recovered. In a boom that runs past the economy's capacity, demand outruns supply and inflation rises, eroding the value of money and of savings. Both are costly, and both feed on themselves through the multiplier and through confidence.
So governments and the Reserve Bank try to smooth the cycle: to add to demand when it is weak and restrain it when it is too strong. A stable cycle also helps the long run, because firms invest and people train more readily when they can plan with confidence.
| Objective | What it means | Measured by |
|---|---|---|
| Sustainable economic growth | Real output growing steadily, at a rate the economy's capacity and the environment can sustain without rising inflation | Real GDP growth, productivity growth |
| Economic prosperity and wellbeing | Rising living standards: higher real incomes, but also health, education, leisure, a clean environment and a fair distribution | Real GDP per capita, real wages, income distribution, wider wellbeing measures |
| Internal stability | Full employment and price stability inside the economy | Unemployment and underemployment rates; CPI inflation against the 2–3% target |
| External stability | Australia's dealings with the rest of the world are sustainable: a manageable current account deficit and foreign debt, and an exchange rate without damaging swings | Current account balance, net foreign debt, the exchange rate |
Match each goal to the objective it serves most directly.
Worked example
Explain the trade-offs in a tax-and-transfer proposal
A government proposes to raise the top marginal income tax rate from 45% to 50% and use the revenue to increase JobSeeker Payment.
Explain how the proposal might improve equity, and the trade-offs it involves with efficiency and with other objectives.
Step 1: Identify the equity gain
A higher top marginal rate makes income tax more progressive (vertical equity: those with the greatest capacity to pay contribute more). A higher JobSeeker Payment is a transfer that raises the incomes of the lowest-income households. Together they reduce income inequality.
Step 2: Identify the efficiency cost
A higher marginal rate lowers the after-tax reward for extra work, saving and investment by high earners, and may encourage tax avoidance. A higher unemployment payment, if not well designed, can weaken the incentive to take up low-paid work. Both could reduce the supply of labour and capital, a cost to efficiency and to growth.
Marginal rates matter for incentives because decisions about extra work and investment depend on the reward for the next dollar.
Step 3: Consider other objectives and the time dimension
Higher transfers to low-income households, who spend most of what they receive, add to consumption and AD, which supports employment in a downturn but adds to inflation pressure near full capacity. If the change lowers investment, potential growth (LRAS) may be a little slower over time: an intertemporal trade-off.
Step 4: Weigh them
How large the efficiency cost is depends on how strongly high earners respond to the rate (evidence suggests responses vary) and on how the payment is designed. The judgement is about how much efficiency society is willing to give up for a given gain in equity.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The proposal improves vertical equity (a more progressive tax and higher transfers to the lowest-income households), but trades off efficiency (weaker incentives to work and invest at the top and possibly at the bottom), may add to demand when the economy is near capacity, and may slow growth over time.
Method
Name the equity gain and the kind of equity.
Explain the efficiency cost through incentives at the margin.
Link to other objectives (AD, inflation, growth) and to now versus later.
Say what the size of the trade-off depends on.
Watch out for
Saying the high earner pays 50% on their whole income: only income above the top threshold is taxed at the top rate.
Calling the proposal good or bad without naming what is gained and what is given up.
Common mistake
Equity is not equality
A fair system can leave incomes unequal. Equity asks whether people are treated fairly given their circumstances and capacity to pay; it does not require everyone to end up with the same.
Explain why a government might try to stabilise the economic cycle rather than let it run its course. (3 marks)
Summary
Governments make economic policy to improve efficiency (allocative, productive, dynamic) where markets fail, and to improve equity (vertical and horizontal).
Every policy involves trade-offs: efficiency against equity, one objective against another, and now against later.
Stabilising the economic cycle avoids the lost output and unemployment of contractions and the inflation of booms.
The objectives: sustainable economic growth, economic prosperity and wellbeing, internal stability (full employment, price stability) and external stability.
Evaluating policy means weighing what it gains against what it costs, and for whom.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.