Lesson 1: Why governments manage the economy
Explain the trade-offs in a tax-and-transfer proposal
SkillWhy governments make economic policy
Worked example
A government proposes to raise the top marginal income tax rate from 45% to 50% and use the revenue to increase JobSeeker Payment.
Explain how the proposal might improve equity, and the trade-offs it involves with efficiency and with other objectives.
Step 1: Identify the equity gain
A higher top marginal rate makes income tax more progressive (vertical equity: those with the greatest capacity to pay contribute more). A higher JobSeeker Payment is a transfer that raises the incomes of the lowest-income households. Together they reduce income inequality.
Step 2: Identify the efficiency cost
A higher marginal rate lowers the after-tax reward for extra work, saving and investment by high earners, and may encourage tax avoidance. A higher unemployment payment, if not well designed, can weaken the incentive to take up low-paid work. Both could reduce the supply of labour and capital, a cost to efficiency and to growth.
Marginal rates matter for incentives because decisions about extra work and investment depend on the reward for the next dollar.
Step 3: Consider other objectives and the time dimension
Higher transfers to low-income households, who spend most of what they receive, add to consumption and AD, which supports employment in a downturn but adds to inflation pressure near full capacity. If the change lowers investment, potential growth (LRAS) may be a little slower over time: an intertemporal trade-off.
Step 4: Weigh them
How large the efficiency cost is depends on how strongly high earners respond to the rate (evidence suggests responses vary) and on how the payment is designed. The judgement is about how much efficiency society is willing to give up for a given gain in equity.
Answer
The proposal improves vertical equity (a more progressive tax and higher transfers to the lowest-income households), but trades off efficiency (weaker incentives to work and invest at the top and possibly at the bottom), may add to demand when the economy is near capacity, and may slow growth over time.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name the equity gain and the kind of equity.
Explain the efficiency cost through incentives at the margin.
Link to other objectives (AD, inflation, growth) and to now versus later.
Say what the size of the trade-off depends on.
Watch out for
Saying the high earner pays 50% on their whole income: only income above the top threshold is taxed at the top rate.
Calling the proposal good or bad without naming what is gained and what is given up.