Lesson 4: Specialisation and the gains from trade
Decide whether proposed terms of trade benefit both countries
SkillSpecialisation and gains from trade
Worked example
Australia needs 4 hours of labour to produce a tonne of wheat and 12 hours to make a laptop; Malaysia needs 10 hours and 15 hours (illustrative). Malaysia proposes to sell laptops to Australia at 1 laptop = 4 tonnes of wheat.
(a) Explain whether Australia should accept. (b) Find a rate at which both would gain, and calculate how many tonnes of wheat Australia saves by importing 10 laptops at that rate instead of making them.
Step 1: Each country's cost of a laptop
Australia: tonnes of wheat per laptop. Malaysia: tonnes per laptop.
Step 2: Judge the proposal
At 4 tonnes per laptop Australia would pay more than the 3 tonnes a laptop costs it to make. Australia should reject it: it gains by making its own laptops.
Step 3: The range at which both gain
Malaysia gains if it receives more than 1.5 tonnes per laptop; Australia gains if it pays less than 3. Any rate with works, for example 1 laptop = 2 tonnes of wheat.
Step 4: Australia's saving on 10 laptops
Making 10 laptops would cost Australia tonnes of wheat. Buying them at 2 tonnes each costs tonnes. Australia saves tonnes of wheat.
The saving is the gain from trade for Australia: the wheat it no longer gives up.
Answer
Reject: 4 tonnes per laptop exceeds Australia's own cost of 3 tonnes. Any rate between 1.5 and 3 tonnes per laptop benefits both; at 1 laptop = 2 tonnes, importing 10 laptops costs 20 tonnes instead of 30, saving Australia 10 tonnes of wheat.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Find each country's opportunity cost of the good being traded.
The terms must lie strictly between the two costs.
The gain is the difference between the cost of making the goods and the cost of buying them.
Watch out for
Using the output-table rule on hours: the cost of a laptop here is hours for a laptop ÷ hours for wheat.
Accepting any rate below Malaysia's cost: Malaysia would not sell below 1.5.